At the 2024 College of Medicine Annual Education Symposium, Dr. Nick Kman moderated a panel titled “Pros and Cons of AI Tools in MedEd at OSU.” Michael Flierl, Eric Fosler-Lussier, Sean Hickey, and Donal O’Mathuna served as panelists.
Please click through the slideshow (below) for the panel presentation. Click here to read through it in an accessible text document.
Links to the resources mentioned are below. Please note that OCS has not adopted and does not support these tools; rather, we present them here simply as resources mentioned by our panelists.
- Claude.ai
- “This uses a ‘constitutional’ model for AI safety reasons. Very large context window meaning you can upload large texts (e.g. a whole novel) to interact with.”
- perplexity.ai
- “An AI that tries to provide citations for its claims. Not particularly good now, but an interesting concept.”
- HuggingChat
- “Best way to try out open-source LLMs like Llama, Vicuna, and Mistral—no account needed.”
- “For a list of the ‘best’ LLMs, you can see this chatbot ‘arena’ which ranks models.”
- “For lit review type of stuff, scite.ai, elicit.com, and consensus.app are all worth checking out.”
- chat.openai.com/gpts
- “Needing a paid subscription to ChatGPT, individuals can easily create custom AIs (or ‘GPTs’ as OpenAI likes to say). And then there’s a marketplace where the best ones get voted to the top. Absolutely worth checking out.”
- futuretools.io
- “An AI-tool aggregator, so it’s a great place to start if you just want to explore and try things out.”
- ChatPDF
- “Allows users to upload or link to academic journal articles, get a summary, and have a GPT-chatbot ‘discussion’ about the article, letting users ask questions. One nice feature is that it takes you directly to the article’s text as a citation to explain its responses to questions.”
- BenAI Assistant
- “A Chrome extension, similar to the Copilot sidebar in the Edge browser. It can analyze the content on your screen if you’re looking at an article or website and provide links to learn more, a summary, and a chatbot-type interface to ask questions.”
- Prompt Engineering for ChatGPT
- “While this isn’t an AI tool, there is a free online course to learn about prompt engineering and how to refine genAI prompts to get the most out of the tool’s output.”
- Expert Reports: Resources on Ethics and AI
- Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) Ethically Aligned Design
- UNESCO (2021) Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence
- White House (2022) Blueprint for an AI Bill of Rights
- “I am still looking for a concise statement that is not superficial, but I think the White House proposal for AI Rights is a very good place to start.”
- World Health Organization (2021) Ethics and governance of artificial intelligence for health
- World Health Organization (2022) Ageism in artificial intelligence for health
- World Health Organization (2024) Ethics and governance of artificial intelligence for health: Guidance on large multi-modal models