In my last post I talked about how Carolina Chickadee songs have changed (or not) in Columbus and the surrounding areas over the past ~60 years. This post takes a different perspective on how Carolina Chickadee songs can vary: over geographic space. If you were paying close attention in the last post, you may have gotten a sense of geographic variation in song even on a scale as small as Columbus – some songs only appeared in certain areas during certain time periods.
One major component of my dissertation here at OSU has been to quantify how Carolina chickadee songs vary over their entire range, the southeastern United States, and compare this variation to geographic variation in their sister species, the Black-capped Chickadee. Despite Carolina Chickadees being very common birds, not many recordings of their songs were archived in museum collections for me to use. The Borror Lab had the most recordings, but the vast majority of those were made in Ohio.
So in spring of 2014 I embarked on an expedition to record as many Carolina Chickadees in as many different places as possible. Over 5 and a half weeks (divided into three trips), I drove about 6,000 miles through 22 states and recorded over 120 chickadees.
Sample locations during recording trip in 2014
Below are samples of some of the atypical songs that I recorded on my trip. The full Carolina chickadee range is shaded in orange. All the spectrograms shown are on the same scale, so you can directly compare them to one another (the upper limit of each spectrogram image is about 10 kHz). Not included are songs or spectrograms of the typical alternating high-low-high-low Carolina chickadee song, which was also present at most sample locations.
- Newark, Delaware
2. Kensington, Maryland
3. Asheboro, North Carolina
4. Cartersville, Georgia
5. Camden, Alabama
6. Ajax, Louisiana
7. Meridian, Texas
8. Moyers, Oklahoma
9. Crossville, Tennessee
10. Salem, Missouri
11. Makanda, Illinois
12. Mammoth Cave, Kentucky
About the author: Stephanie Wright Nelson is a graduate student in the department of EEOBiology. She studies song learning in chickadees and is particularly interested in the consequences of hybridization between Carolina and Black-capped Chickadees.
Fascinating post! Ajax, Louisiana, Meridian, Texas, and Makanda, Illinois were my favorites! I’ve read that there is more song variation farther away from the overlap zone. Did you find this to be true in your travels?
I’m glad I found your post on regional variation https://777-pub.com.ph/
I’m glad I found your post on regional variation. I live in Norman, Oklahoma, and I’ve been hearing what sounds like a three note whistle (High Low … Lower) with a pause between the second and third note. But after listening to your examples from Oklahoma and Missouri, I’m convinced that it’s actually a four-note whistle whose third very high pitched note I’m not able to hear.
https://789alo.pro/ 789alo is currently recognized as a leading reward entertainment venue in Asia. Every day, this brand attracts hundreds of thousands of downloads and visitors to participate in betting. The publisher owns its own store of top-notch games with Asian-class quality to meet all the entertainment needs of customers globally. If you are planning to participate in betting here, you should not miss this article!
https://18win1.org/ 18win is currently one of the units with the most regular number of players participating every day. Here, you will not only experience top entertainment products but also have the opportunity to become a billionaire if you are lucky. Our following article will help you better understand this platform before registering to participate.
https://n6666.org/ N666 is currently at the top of the list of the world’s most quality online companies. This brand is present in the Vietnamese market and is well received by many players. To understand more about why, please refer to the basic article we are about to share below.
I’m truly impressed with Nhà Cái Red88 how this article breaks down and explains the aspects of the topic. Everything is explained in a scientific yet accessible way, making it easy for readers like me to grasp and apply in real life. This is a highly valuable read!
Thank you to the author for presenting such a useful and comprehensive article. The content is clearly written, easy to understand, and backed by real-world examples, which makes me trust the information shared. This is definitely a great reference! Nhà cái Bet88
This article is truly valuable with its rich information and logical, coherent explanations. I really appreciate the author’s thorough research, as the points made are well-analyzed and persuasive Nhà cái GO99
I enjoyed reading this article it offers valuable insights and the content is well organized and thorough 98win
This is a very good article I found it valuable it helped me vf http://shbet111.net/
This article is of great value. kudos to the author lk https://33win.camp/
This is a great insightful article I love it ip http://hello88.vegas/
Thank you to the author for presenting such a useful and comprehensive article. The content is clearly written, easy to understand, and backed by real-world examples, which makes me trust the information shared. This is definitely a great reference! https://pg88.black/
Thanks to the author for a clear, useful, and well-supported article. It’s a trustworthy and great reference! https://bet88.ventures/
Grateful to the author for delivering a concise, valuable, and well-supported piece. It’s reliable and a fantastic resource! https://rr88.pink/
Great insights in this article thanks for putting it out there gw Jun88
Thank you for sharing this valuable information a 77bet
The article is very high quality I will share it hl FCB88
Thanks to the author for sharing such a helpful article. The content is clear https://lodeonline.solar/
I appreciate the author for providing such a detailed and insightful article. https://xxin88.com/the-thao/
Grateful to the author for delivering such a valuable and in-depth article! https://bongdalu.solar/
this is the best answer i have ever heard nổ hũ 23win good game
this is the best answer i have ever heard game bài 23win love life
Why did I just find out about this great article now lk ABC8 social is my love
Thank you for this good article it explains everything https://vipfb88.com/
Thank you for this great article https://nhatvip.villas/
Thanks for sharing this wonderful piece https://99ok.buzz/
This was such a captivating read, and I wanted to express my thanks. https://may88.moda/
I truly enjoyed this and wanted to thank you for the effort you put into it. https://good88.exchange/
This was an excellent read, and I appreciate you taking the time to write it. https://shbet.law/
Very intriguing Exactly what I had hoped to find https://iwinbet88.com/
Super helpful Just the information I was after https://five88.villas/
Fantastic details Precisely what I was looking for https://j88hatomi.com/
Really engaging info Perfect match for what I needed https://98win.forex/
Such fascinating information Just what I was hoping to find https://abc8.irish/
Great insight Exactly the kind of thing I needed https://cwin8386.com/
Spot on This is exactly what I was after https://33winbee.com/
This info is incredibly useful Exactly what I was hoping for https://good88.wedding/
This is just what I was hoping for – very helpful. https://ww88abo.com/
Exactly what I needed this is so useful. https://98win.pink/
The information provided is spot on and very beneficial. https://abc8bc.shop/
This is precisely the kind of detail I was looking for. https://yeu88.red/
I really appreciate what I learned here iuw 23win joushua filler
This article is highly informative iop 77win
This content is perfect – exactly what I was hoping to find. https://hello88.gratis/
It’s incredibly beneficial and precisely what I was after. https://abc8.foundation/
nothing is more important than knowledge thank you 98win
This information meets my expectations and is highly valuable. https://789winmb.com/
Very insightful and exactly what I wanted to find. https://8386ww88.com/
Just the kind of detail I was searching for; highly practical. https://thabeta.com/
Perfectly suited to what I was looking for; very informative. https://88clb.market/
Perfectly suited to what I was looking for; very informative. 88clb
This is highly practical and exactly what I needed. https://gk88.vc/
The details here are exactly what I was hoping to come across. https://789winn.mobi/
Just what I wanted to find; insightful and useful. https://98win.claims/
Precisely what I was searching for; this is very informative. kuwin.gg
This is exactly the kind of useful information I needed. https://gk88.photo/
The perfect response to what I was hoping for – truly helpful. http://88clb.deal/
Pututogel has something for everyone. Pututogel
The exact kind of useful insight I was searching for. https://ok9.mom/
This is just what I needed – very comprehensive and helpful. https://789clubb.la/
Exactly aligned with what I wanted; truly beneficial. https://zbet8.org/
This meets my requirements perfectly; very valuable. WW88
This matches exactly what I was searching for and is very helpful. https://88vin.ing/
Highly valuable information and precisely what I wanted to find. https://18windo.cfd/
This is exactly the valuable information I was seeking. https://b52clubdo.com/
The perfect information I’ve been looking for! https://69vnnet.vip/
Exactly what I needed to find; this is great. https://79win.ing/
This is the kind of valuable insight I was hoping to discover. fb88
Truly valuable details, just as I had hoped to find. https://vvvwinlt.com/
This is precisely the answer I needed. https://23winlt.com/
Completely aligned with my expectations; very helpful. ABC 8
Exactly the kind of information I’ve been hunting for! RED88
I couldn’t have asked for a more perfect response. https://789club.college/
Exactly what I wanted—this is highly valuable. https://99ok.feedback/
This is just the kind of value I was hoping to get. https://88clblink.com/
Just what I needed this information is incredibly useful. https://hello88com.wtf/
This is the precise knowledge I’ve been searching for. https://ww88.cruises/
Thank you for the insightful article I had been caught in a loop with this challenge but your solution has given me the clarity and direction to finally make progress DEBET
Exactly the kind of insight I was hoping to find. abc8 com
This is right on point and exactly what I was looking for. https://fun88dl.vip/
Couldn’t have found a more suitable answer thank you https://kuwinn.cc/
This is exactly the detailed information I needed. https://789betgreen.com/
This is a highly valuable response just what I wanted. https://hello88.international/
Just the clarification I was hoping to receive. https://qq88.works/
This is the information I been trying to track down https://8888b.fun/
This perfectly answers my question very valuable. 88CLB
Exactly what I had in mind thank you so much https://pdphotoblog.com/
Couldn’t have asked for better this is spot on trang chủ 789bet
This is the exact information I was after. https://cwin886.red/
Truly insightful and matches my search perfectly. https://sv66.express/