White-Nose Syndrome (WNS) effects on Bat Populations

Bat Populations across North America have been dwindling over the past decade due to the introduction of Pseudogymnoascus destructans, also known as White-Nose Syndrome (WNS).  This pathogen is a fungal disease that originated in Eurasia before it was introduced to the United States.  The first confirmed case of White-Nose Syndrome was in 2007, when scientists discovered many dead bats in a cave in Albany, New York. However, there were earlier suspected cases from 2005 to 2006.  The exact cause of the fungal disease’s introduction to North America is still unknown, though most scientists agree that its origin was likely linked to humans indirectly (Hoyt et al., 2021).

The disease has spread all over North America at a rate of 200 km/year to 900 km/year in the first eight years.  This is now in 39 states in the US and 7 Canadian provinces. WNS is typically spread to bats through direct contact with infected individuals or environments.  Figure 1 below shows the cycle of how the disease spreads.  The graph in Figure 1 indicates that the disease infections begin in August/September and begin to peak in November/December.  WNS will persist through winter and decrease around May when spring approaches.  This coincides with bats’ hibernation, as depicted in Figure 1.  The disease infects bats in the winter months when the bats are hibernating and in close contact with each other.  Some bats will survive the disease, while others will die of the infection.  The bats will begin to recover during summer since they are outdoors more.  When they return the following winter for hibernation, they risk infection again (Hoyt et al., 2021).

Figure 1: How Whtie-Nose Syndrome Spreads

(Hoyt et al., 2021)

            The disease affects bats the most during the winter when they are in their hibernation state.  They are vulnerable during hibernation because it makes them active while attempting to conserve energy (White-nose Syndrome Response Team, What Is White-nose Syndrome?). Figure 2 depicts the disease’s physiological effects on bats. The disease starts by causing damage to the bat’s tissue, increasing the bat’s metabolic rates.  An accelerated metabolic rate can cause the temperature of the bats to rise, leading to dehydration and loss of vital electrolytes. Additionally, the metabolic rate increase leads to energy reserve loss and fat reduction.  These factors combined have led to the increased mortality of multiple bat species (Hoyt et al., 2021).

 

Figure 2: Physiological Effects of White-Nose Syndrome on Bat Populations

(Hoyt et al., 2021)

Many different efforts are being made to help slow down the spread of the disease.  One such team, the White-Nose Syndrome Response Team, implements these conservation efforts to save multiple species of bats.  One such method is biological, which involves applying a bacterium to the bats known as Rhodococcus rhodochrous. This bacterium has features that help kill the disease.  The team uses different chemicals to kill the disease and prevent its spread. An example of this is Polyethylene glycol (PEG) 8000.  Progress is being made to create a vaccine for the bats.  Scientists are also changing habitat conditions, such as the temperature, to make it less ideal for the disease to grow (White-nose Syndrome Response Team. Helping Bats Survive).

Citations

Hoyt JR, Kilpatrick AM, Langwig KE (2021) Ecology and Impacts of White-Nose Syndrome on Bats. Nature Reviews Microbiology. 19: 196–210.

White-nose Syndrome Response Team. What Is White-nose Syndrome? https://www.whitenosesyndrome.org/static-page/what-is-white-nose-syndrome ((date last accessed 2 April 2024)

White-nose Syndrome Response Team. Helping Bats Survive. https://www.whitenosesyndrome.org/static-page/helping-bats-survive ((date last accessed 2 April 2024)

Big City Bats

An LED Floodlight, Image by Leon Brooks. Retrieved from https://pixnio.com/objects/electronics-devices/electric-lights-pictures/stadium-lights

Throughout the world, more and more people are living in urban areas. We’re called by the glimmering lights, the whirlwind of activity, the sights and sounds of the big city. Some of these same factors that draw people to cities are what drive other animals away–or, in many cases, cause harm to the animals who stay.

For bats, who are most active at night, urban light pollution can pose some major issues (Laforge et al., 2019; Langley, 2019; Seewagen and Adams, 2021). Artificial light can be disorienting for nocturnal animals, disrupting their circadian cycles and changing their typical activity levels throughout the day (Seewagen and Adams, 2021). Further, high levels of light leave species that are used to the cover of darkness vulnerable to predators (Cravens and Boyles, 2018; Laforge et al., 2019). Still, some bats–individuals or entire species–choose to spend more time foraging in lighter areas because UV lights attract their preferred food choice: insects (Cravens and Boyles, 2018; Langley, 2019; Seewagen and Adams, 2021).

So how does the presence of light impact the bats who choose to stay?

Seewagen and Adams (2021) found that several species of bats reacted to the presence of LED floodlights by greatly reducing their foraging activity. Migratory tree bats tended to not be impacted by light or even be attracted to it, while nonmigratory species tended to avoid light areas (Seewagen and Adams, 2021). Little brown bats (Myotis lucifugus) have been found to have difficulty avoiding obstacles in highly-illuminated areas, indicating that light may have some impact on their sensory systems, including systems involved in orientation (Seewagen and Adams, 2021).

Little Brown Bat, Image by Moriarty Marvin, USFWS. Retrieved from https://pixnio.com/fauna-animals/bats-pictures/myotis-lucifugus-little-brown-bat

Cravens and Boyles (2018) focused on the differences between levels of the blood metabolite beta-hydroxybutyrate in bats found in lit and unlit conditions. Beta-hydroxybutyrate is a fasting metabolite, and is used for energy in metabolic processes when triglyceride fat storage is low. Interestingly, this is not the exact case in bats: beta-hydroxybutyrate levels spike after feeding–so they are correlated with periods of intense exercise (Cravens and Boyles, 2018). For red bats (Lasiurus borealis), beta-hydroxybutyrate levels were highest just after sunset in highly-lit sites, while the opposite was true in dark sites (Cravens and Boyles, 2018). Cravens and Boyles (2018) suggest that red bats have altered their foraging activity to prey on insects at lit sites just after sunset, while other bats may forage throughout the night. Also, red bats captured at lights late at night had low levels of these blood metabolites, suggesting that they were able to gain more energy from well-lit areas with less work (Cravens and Boyles, 2018).

Despite this positive impact on foraging in some bat species, high levels of light pollution can negatively impact bat diversity and species abundance in urban areas (Laforge et al., 2019; Langley, 2019; Seewagen and Adams, 2021). Seewagen and Adams (2021) were only able to detect little brown bats on 14% of light nights, while they were able to hear little brown bats calling on 65% of dark nights. Laforge et al. (2019) had similar results, with artificial light being a significant predictor of bat presence and activity, as well as their ability to move through their landscapes.

While artificial nighttime light can provide light-tolerant bats with novel foraging opportunities, finding ways to mitigate the impacts of nighttime light can greatly improve bat biodiversity. The most obvious solution is to turn out the lights–reducing nighttime light can help bats expand their species range by providing opportunities to safely move between habitat patches (Laforge et al., 2019). With less light, bats will be better able to avoid predators, and their sensory systems and circadian cycles may fall back in line. However, reducing light is not enough to truly improve bats’ habitat quality (Laforge et al., 2019)–and it is not the only option. Increasing urban greenspace can provide bats with shelter from predators in the form of tree canopy cover (Langley, 2019). Bats may even be able to strike a balance–enjoying the benefits of insects attracted to UV lights while remaining safely covered (Langley, 2019).

Whatever the solution may be, one thing is for sure: providing safe habitats for bats is necessary for supporting pollination, controlling insect populations, and preserving biodiversity in a changing world.

Works Cited

Cravens, ZM & Boyles, JG (2019) Illuminating the physiological implications of artificial light on an insectivorous bat community. Oecologia 189:69-77. doi: 10.1007/s00442-018-4300-6

Laforge, A, Pauwels, K, Faure, B, Bas, Y, Kerbiriou, C, Fonderflick, J, & Besnard, A (2019) Reducing light pollution improves connectivity for bats in urban landscapes. Landsc Ecol 34:793-809. doi: 1o.1007/s10980-019-00803-0

Langley, L (2019, April 17) Light pollution hurts urban bats. Trees can help. National Geographic. https://www.nationalgeographic.com/animals/article/bats-appreciation-day-cities-urban-lights

Seewagen CL & Adams, AM (2021) Turning to the dark side: LED light at night alters the activity and species composition of a foraging bat assemblage in the northeastern United States. Ecol Evol 11(10):5635-5645

Image 1 source: https://pixnio.com/objects/electronics-devices/electric-lights-pictures/stadium-lights

Image 2 source: https://pixnio.com/fauna-animals/bats-pictures/myotis-lucifugus-little-brown-bat