Corporal Punishment in India

by

In class today, we talked about corporal punishment and its prevalence in schools in Mississippi. In this post, I would like to discuss corporal punishment as I have witnessed it in my home country of India and offer a reason based on cultural relativism for why I think it exists even today despite being illegal.

Although there are many forms of corporal punishment, the one I have witnessed most commonly in Indian schools is the spanking of students by the teachers. What I found particularly surprising from my experience was that in one of the schools I attended, students from all grades were subject to this form of corporal punishment. This included children of all ages, from the youngest to the oldest. Supposedly, this instills in the children a sense of discipline, but does it really do so directly? I strongly feel it does not — instead, I believe it instills in students a sense of fear, which in turn “disciplines” them. That is, students are taught to behave properly out of fear of the consequences of misbehaving. This is especially powerful in extreme cases of corporal punishment, which in India can include forcing students to sit outside on their knees in blazing hot temperatures (often upwards of 100 degrees Fahrenheit) for hours on end.

Given this information, I ask a stupidly obvious question: is corporal punishment moral? Of course, I believe not. How then is there justification for its prevalence in India? From a cultural relativist standpoint, I believe that those who support corporal punishment in India fail to see that an objective moral truth regarding this practice exists (even though the Indian government has declared it illegal). That is, these individuals do not realize that corporal punishment is morally wrong and would likely argue that since society does not condemn the practice (i.e. it is prevalent despite having been declared illegal by the government), it is morally acceptable. However, I feel that the value behind corporal punishment is the same as that behind any other form of child disciplining: to teach children what is right and wrong. Why, then, do teachers in India exercise corporal punishment to teach students right and wrong when the same goal can be accomplished by more humane methods (i.e. timeouts)? Personally, I feel it is because throughout Indian history, disciplining children by corporal punishment has been the norm, so society has come to accept it as moral. That being said, when will all of Indian society realize it is immoral?

121 thoughts on “Corporal Punishment in India”

  1. Initially, upon reading this article I believed that spanking could actually help children learn discipline, and therefore could be seen as moral in certain occasions (certainly not the ones you described, however). I did some external researching and found that other methodology for punishment is actually much more effective! (See link referenced below). Therefore, I now see how your argument is valid and sound, and definitely agree with you!

    http://www.babycenter.com/0_spanking-grounding-and-yelling-does-old-fashioned-discipline_3657191.bc

    Reply

    • Dear Kevin, I don’t think that spanking or any other methods of physical influence on children can be useful in their upbringing. Besides, such practices of upbringing and punishing children can be applied to them only by their parents, but not by strangers or readers as it happens in India. I visited India for the first time only in 2024. The team of the tourist service portal Visit Ukraine, which itself often visits tourist exhibitions around the world, helped me with this trip. I must say that India made a double impression on me. On the one hand, it is certainly an ancient civilization with a deep culture and spirituality, but on the other hand, the garbage on the streets and the use of physical punishment in society are somewhat depressing.

      Reply

  22. The Small Business Administration uses the number of employees working at a company and its annual revenue to formally define a small business. For 229 industry sectors, from engineering and manufacturing to food service and real estate, the SBA sets sizing standards every five years. Increase the sales reduce the costs optimise the profit.
    Author Cindi Howson, an experienced Business Intelligence analyst, details how to successfully integrate BI in business in this book. Rather than simply discussing the theories behind BI, she dives into the best strategies used by successful organizations. Howson covers everything your business will need for getting into BI, from how to customize BI strategy to business goals, to choosing the right applications and getting the right training. She notes the need for quality data and that there’s no single way to measure success. Read more visit link.

    Reply

  23. Most countries with capital markets have at least one. In many countries, it is difficult to compile all the laws that can affect a business into a single reference source. Different structures are treated differently in tax law and may have advantages for this reason. For a topical guide, see Outline of business management.

    In most countries, there are laws that treat small corporations differently from large ones. They may be exempt from certain legal filing requirements or labor laws, have simplified procedures in specialized areas, and have simplified, advantageous, or slightly different tax treatment. Where two or more individuals own a business together but have failed to organize a more specialized form of vehicle, they will be treated as a general partnership. Read more visit page.

    The terms of a partnership are partly governed by a partnership agreement if one is created, and partly by the law of the jurisdiction where the partnership is located. A single person who owns and runs a business is commonly known as a sole proprietor, whether that person owns it directly or through a formally organized entity. Depending on the business needs, an adviser can decide what kind is proprietorship will be most suitable.

    Reply

  26. This is a very good post. I just want to say that I found your blog and I am very happy to read your posts about 토토사이트 . I will be subscribing to your blog and hope you write again soon.

    Reply

  27. Gracias, recientemente he estado buscando información sobre este tema durante años y el tuyo es lo mejor que he descubierto.
    hasta ahora. Pero, ¿qué pasa con la conclusión? Eres tú
    positivo en lo que respecta a la fuente?

    https://www.bacarasite.com/

    Reply

  29. Agen Slot Online Bigo88 Merupakan situs slot online terbaik di indonesia. dengan ribuan macam permain slot yang di hadirkan disitus Bigo88 membuat member menjadi mudah untuk mencari permainan yang gacor. Tanpa di ragukan lagi main disitus Bigo88 sudah pasti untung dan menyenangkan.

    Reply

  30. Selamat datang untuk para pecinta slot online Indonesia, dimana Agen Slot Online Madu88 akan merekomendasikan slot gacor dengan winrate terbaik 98%. Untuk bermain slot online di situs slot online sebenarnya bukan hal sulit yang harus dipikirkan.

    Reply

  31. Agen Slot Terpercaya Dewataspin Merupakan Agen Slot Yang Bisa Anda mainkan dimana pun dan kapan pun Anda ingin bermain, langsung buka situs resmi Dewataspin dan langsung memainkan permainan apa saja yang ingin Anda mainkan, Anda bisa langsung membuktikannya sendiri hanya dengan memainkan satu user ID saja di situs gacor Dewataspin sekarang. Kunjungi situs resmi Kami Disini Link Slot Gacor.

    Reply

  35. Gracias, recientemente he estado buscando información sobre este tema durante años y el tuyo es lo mejor que he descubierto.
    hasta ahora. Pero, ¿qué pasa con la conclusión? Eres tú
    positivo en lo que respecta a la fuente? https://darantech.com/

    Reply

  36. Initially, upon reading this article I believed that spanking could actually help children learn discipline, and therefore could be seen as moral in certain occasions (certainly not the ones you described, however). I did some external researching and found that other methodology for punishment is actually much more effective! (See link referenced below). Therefore, I now see how your argument is valid and sound, and definitely agree with you! https://www.wisdomusb.com/

    Reply

  37. Welcome to SMM Panel One, the premier SMM panel that will supercharge your social media presence like never before! Our platform offers a wide range of powerful tools and services to help individuals, influencers, and businesses skyrocket their online visibility and engagement across various social media platforms. From gaining thousands of followers, likes, and shares to running targeted ad campaigns and monitoring analytics, SMM Panel One is your one-stop solution for all your social media marketing needs. Unleash the true potential of your brand and dominate the digital landscape with our intuitive, user-friendly interface and affordable packages. Join the SMM Panel One community today and take control of your social media success!

    Reply

  44. Gracias, recientemente he estado buscando información sobre este tema durante años y el tuyo es lo mejor que he descubierto.
    hasta ahora. Pero, ¿qué pasa con la conclusión? Eres tú
    positivo en lo que respecta a la fuente?
    정품시알리스

    Reply

  45. PaybyplateMA is a new and innovative way to pay bills online. Instead of sending your invoice by mail, you can use your PaybyPlateMa account to pay immediately with a debit or credit card or even with your mobile phone.With a registered MA Pay-by-Plate account, you can easily pay your tolls with your gray card. In addition, users enjoy various discounts after registering on this portal. Users can only take advantage of these discounts after registering on this portal. paybyplateMA

    Reply

  62. Tolkien’s philosophy – Bard is a grim, serious man who first appears in The Hobbit as the Captain of the guard in the town of Lake-town. He is descended from the ancient line of Girion, the last lord of the city of Dale before it was destroyed by the dragon Smaug.

    Reply

  63. Thank you for sharing your perspective on corporal punishment in Indian schools. It’s disheartening to hear about the prevalence of such practices, especially considering the harmful effects it can have on students.

    Justin – OPManager @ Office cleaning Melbourne

    Reply

  64. Transform your salon effortlessly with TipTop-Einrichtung’s comprehensive Friseursalon Einrichtung komplett. We specialise in offering hassle-free solutions to enhance your hairdressing space. Elevate your salon experience with our simple yet sophisticated complete furnishings.

    Reply

  65. What is nuru massage?
    Nuru massage, a form of body to body massage originating from Japan, has gained popularity worldwide for its unique blend of sensual and therapeutic benefits. In this article, we delve into the origins, techniques, benefits, and etiquette surrounding nuru massage.

    Reply

  66. For what spa69 is known for?
    Sp69 is one of the best b2b spa near me that i ever visited. In Bangalore it will be best choice for body to body massage so don’t miss any offers book now

    Reply

  69. Can I say what relief to find someone who really knows what theyre discussing on the net. You definitely have learned to bring a difficulty to light making it important. The diet should look at this and understand why side on the story. I cant believe youre less common simply because you definitely possess the gift. Melasma cream with SPF protection

    Reply

  73. I wish to show my appreciation for your generosity for persons that actually need help on in this niche. Your special dedication to passing the solution throughout ended up being rather significant and have continually encouraged somebody much like me to attain their dreams. Your personal warm and helpful useful information indicates a great deal a person like me and even more to my peers. Best wishes; from each one of us. Security Pact

    Reply

  77. You realize your activities stand apart of the crowd. Something stands out about them. It appears to me every one of them are truly splendid! click

    Reply

  85. Enjoy flawless streaming on all devices with KEMO IPTV Pack, built to prevent buffering and freezing, delivering brilliant 4K image quality, no matter where you are or when you watch : KEMO IPTV

    Reply

  86. Stream without interruption thanks to the MOM IPTV Pack’s anti-buffering and anti-freeze features, paired with incredible 4K image quality on any device, wherever you are : MOM IPTV

    Reply

  87. Experience seamless streaming with OTTOCEAN IPTV Pack, offering anti-buffering and anti-freeze technology and delivering crisp image quality up to 4K on any device, anytime, anywhere : OTTOCEAN IPTV

    Reply

  89. Looking for the best selection of used cars in Vancouver? Vancouver Pre-Owned offers an extensive inventory of pre-owned cars, used trucks, and exotic cars at unbeatable prices. Whether you need a family-friendly SUV, a fuel-efficient electric car, or a luxury sports car, we have the perfect vehicle for you.

    Reply

  91. “Great piece on the topic of corporal punishment in India! I have to say, I was struck by the mention of the importance of discipline and respect in maintaining social order. It’s fascinating to explore the philosophical underpinnings of such issues, and how they relate to our daily lives. By the way, after reading this blog, I feel compelled to share my own personal experience of booking a helicopter ride to Amarnath for a spiritual pilgrimage. The breathtaking views from above were truly divine! But I digress. Overall, your blog has given me much to think about, and I look forward to continuing the discussion on this topic. Well-written and thought-provoking!” Amarnath Helicopter Booking

    Reply

  93. Thanks so much for the time and effort you put into this article. It was a big help for my project. I’m now a fan of this site and can’t wait to see what’s next. Great job—keep it up! – 24kbet

    Reply

  96. Great article! The explanations here are clear and easy to understand, which is really helpful for students and educators alike. I also came across an interesting discussion about digital literacy on bakar77. Looking forward to reading more useful posts from this blog.

    Reply

  100. We are one of the best body massage service providers in bangalore.
    We are one of the best b2b massage in bangalore.
    We are one of the best happy ending massage in bangalore.
    We are one of the best female to male body massage in bangalore.

    Reply

  102. Pker88 sebagai situs pker online penyedia game resmi dan terpercaya dengan layanan daftar pker88 dan permainan seru dari situs IDN Pker dengan sistem fair play bonus besar. Situs pker88

    Reply

  106. Thank you so much for such a well-written article. It’s full of insightful information. Your point of view is the best among many without fail. For certain, It is one of the best blogs in my opinion. HENG36 – เฮง36

    Reply

  110. At Bakhtiari & Harrison, we focus on quality, aggressive advocacy, rigorous preparation and client focused results. We bring decades of experience and the resources to offer personalized service tailored to your needs. We understand the unique needs and concerns of each client and implement an effective and compelling strategy from the outset. Bakhtiari & Harrison offers top-tier expertise in securities arbitration and litigation.finra broker check

    Reply

  116. One of my favorite things about Csino Online is the overall flow of the platform. Navigating through different sections feels natural and cohesive, making the entire experience comfortable from start to finish. Csino Online

    Reply

  117. I’ve had nothing but positive experiences with Citislots. Whether accessing from home or while traveling, it remains stable and responsive, making it a reliable choice. Citislots

    Reply

Leave a Reply to look After Babies Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *