Benjamin Libet’s Experiments on Free Will

In class the last couple of weeks, we have been discussing the free will debate. In this post, I would like to bring to light an old research study pertaining to free will. Benjamin Libet was a famous 20th century neuroscientist who conducted groundbreaking research on the neurobiology of consciousness. In one of his classic experiments, Libet taped electrodes to the intact scalp of his study volunteers in an attempt to measure the correspondence of electrical signals from their brains. His goal was to measure this correspondence of electrical signals when the volunteers moved their wrists. The volunteers were required to look at a moving clock and take note of the precise time (to the millisecond) that they consciously decided to move their wrist. Following data collection, Libet compared the timing of brain activity with the timing of the volunteers’ decisions to move their wrist. His results showed that the volunteers’ brain activities preceded their conscious awareness of the decision to move their wrists by ~200 milliseconds.

Libet’s results sparked a debate about whether the volunteers’ decisions to move their wrists was predetermined or an act of free will. Those supporting the former claimed that because the volunteers’ brain activities preceded their decisions, it was in essence “predetermined” that the volunteers would subsequently move their wrist. On the other hand, those arguing for the free will side such as Libet himself claimed that there was a possibility for the volunteers to override the brain’s “proposal” to move the wrist at a given time. For instance, Libet argued that there was a brief period between the initiation of brain activity and the volunteers’ awareness of the intention to act during which they could “veto” the brain’s decision to initiate movement a moment after. If they did so, then they would prolong the initiation of movement. In this way, Libet argued that the volunteers exercised free will in deciding to veto the brain activity.

Libet’s justification reminds me of Kane’s businesswoman example in his article about free will, in which she has two conflicting decisions but ends up choosing one voluntarily (out of free will). In the same way, I feel that Libet’s volunteers must have had this internal conflict (whether to initiate movement a moment after as the brain specified or veto the brain’s decision), but consciously chose one (to veto the brain’s decision) over the other as an act of free will. As such, I feel that the free will defense of Libet’s experiments is more plausible than the determinism defense.


279 thoughts on “Benjamin Libet’s Experiments on Free Will

  1. ورق پلکسی یک ماده ساختمانی مقاوم و متناسب با متنوعیت زیادی از نیازهای طراحی و ساخت است. این ورق، از پلی متیل متاکریلات (PMMA) ساخته می‌شود و به عنوان یک جایگزین مناسب برای شیشه شفاف شناخته می‌شود. ویژگی‌های ورق پلکسی شامل سبکی، ضربه‌پذیری کمتر نسبت به شیشه، مقاومت در برابر تغییرات آب و هوا، و قابلیت شکل‌دهی آسان به صورت حرارتی می‌شود. از این رو، در معماری، تبلیغات، و صنایع دیگر بسیاری از کاربردهای متنوعی دارد.
    ورق پلکسی گلاس

  2. Infinite yield is a Roblox Admin script with many advanced commands to exploit Roblox game. Infinite Yield gives you the ultimate control over your gameplay and the ability to climb the ranks. But it’s not just a script. The best thing about Infinite Yield script is that it can be easily customized to your liking. Using this script, there will be no limitations on how many items you can gathered through Infinite Yield script.

  3. LELE247 ialah situs game judi online 24jam terpercaya yang Sediakan banyak tipe game judi semacam, taruhan bola, c4sino, p0ker online, tembak ikan, sabung ayam. Kamu tidak wajib merasa repot lagi mencari situs judi lain yang belum pasti dapat membagikan kemenangan. Sebab cuma dengan 1 akun kamu telah dapat memainkan seluruh tipe game judi24 online terpercaya secara lengkap.

  4. Judi bola merupakan permainan taruhan olahraga yang ada di situs judi bola terpercaya KUDABET yang paling banyak diminati bettor. Sebagai Agen Bola Piala DuniaTerpercaya KUDABET juga menyediakan berbagai permainan judi taruhan olahraga lain dimana juga, dapat bettor mainkan disini. Karena pada dasarnya, pada taruhan judi sports atau olahraga ini, setiap player akan diharuskan menebak skor hasil pertandingan.

  5. Daftarkan Sekarang User ID Anda Di situs Dan Mainkan Penyedia Game Slot online Yang Terpercaya dan terbaik di kelas nya asia Dengan judi uang asli secara online. Situs Kami Merupakan salah satu Agen situs Game Slot Terpercaya Diindonesia. Daftar Sekarang Juga Di Agen slot Online Madu88 Kami memberikan dukungan RTP slot pragmatic dan pola slot maxwin yang sangat terpercayaSetiap Hari Nya.

  6. Jayaspin adalah situs Slot Online terkemuka yang telah dikenal karena keamanan dan integritasnya. Namun, selalu penting untuk memastikan keamanan informasi pribadi dan keuangan Anda dengan memilih metode pembayaran yang terpercaya dan mengikuti praktik keamanan online yang disarankan.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *