Family Treatment Drug Courts (FTDC) have shown such promise in the US, that they are utilized at an international level. In England, Family Drug and Alcohol Courts (FDAC) use an integrated approach similar to FTDCs in the US, where the same judge oversees both the care proceedings and the treatment intervention. In contrast to some American FTDCs, if parents don’t follow their FPAC plan, the case goes back to being public law care proceedings where authorities still must prove the child is at risk and the FDAC has no further involvement.
The London FDAC was evaluated for long-term outcomes before FDAC was implemented in other regions in England. All London FDAC cases from January 2008 to August 2012 were tracked for up to five years after the intervention. The cohort was compared to cases that weren’t provided FDAC. Thirty-six percent of FDAC mothers had previously removed children, 37% had mental health problems, and 71% had experienced domestic violence. The majority of children (87%) of the cases were brought because of neglect, 25% had emotional and behavioral difficulties, and 41% had physical health problems.
Overall, FDAC mothers had better outcomes than comparison mothers. Forty-six percent of FDAC mothers stopped misusing substances, compared to only 30% of the comparison mothers ceased. Thirty-seven percent of FDAC families either continued to live together or were reunited vs. 25% of comparison familiesFifty-eight percent of FDAC mothers sustained the reunification compared to only 24% of the comparison mothers. However, there was no difference in the amount of time it took for the child to be permanently placed. The study also found that the first two years after the reunification was especially risky for mothers. However, about a fifth of all children (both FDAC and comparison) were estimated to change placements after they had received their permanent placement. This study shows evidence of positive, long-lasting effects from FDAC. Additional support for the first two years following FDAC may need to be offered, as this study showed that it is a vulnerable time for families.
Harwin J, Alrouh B, Broadhurst K, McQuarrie T, Golding L, Ryan M. 2018. Child and parent outcomes in the London Family Drug and Alcohol Court five years on: building on international evidence. International Journal of Law, Policy and the Family 32(2): 140–169. https://doi.org/10.1093/lawfam/eby006.