One of my favorite comedy shows is South Park. Most episodes of South Park take serious issues and add a comedic spin to them. One episode in particular relates to our class discussions on gender identity. The episode is titled “The Cissy” and begins with one of the main characters, Eric Cartman, entering the men’s restroom only to find both stalls in use. He realizes he won’t be able to use the men’s restroom so instead he puts a bow on his head and uses the women’s restroom. The girls are disgusted and Cartman has to meet with the principal to address the situation. Cartman lies and claims he’s “transginger”, meaning transgender, and for that reason he is allowed to use the women’s restroom. The school realizes they are unable to win this battle and solve the problem by creating a transgender restroom. Wendy, one of the girls upset with Cartman’s lie, then claims to also be transgender and starts to use the transgender restroom. An angry Cartman then tells Wendy’s boyfriend Stan he is a girl since Wendy claims to be a guy. Stan goes to his father Randy for answers unaware that Randy is going through a gender crisis of his own. Randy lives a double life as he is an average father, but is also secretly the pop star Lorde. A similar situation is going on at Lorde/Randy’s work as the women are uncomfortable with him using the women’s restroom. Inspired by his wife, Lorde/Randy produces a new hit song. The song moves the women at Randy’s work to allow him to use the women’s restroom and the school decides to remove the transgender restroom and allow the student’s to choose whichever restroom they are most comfortable with, except for those who are uncomfortable using a bathroom with transgender people who get a separate bathroom. In an ironic ending, the former transgender bathroom is now labelled the cissy bathroom for people who are uncomfortable with transgender people.
The episode intentionally exaggerates the misunderstandings and stereotypes associated with transgender people. When the principal asserts that Cartman doesn’t even know what transgender means, Cartman claims to have looked it up online and responds by saying, “It means I live a life of torture and confusion because society sees me as a boy, but I’m really a girl”. Cartman’s definition stereotypes transgender people to be living a life of pain where they are uncomfortable with who they are and the way society views them. The principal doesn’t even object to his definition, accepting it as the correct one, further showing how those who are not transgender view transgender people.
The episode presents another misconception when it comes to transgender people and sexuality. The principal claims Cartmen must be attracted to boys since he identifies as a girl. Cartman refutes this claim by saying this is untrue and citing the state bi-laws. Cartman, not really being transgender and needing to get back at Wendy, goes against this approach and claims Stan must be girl since Wendy identifies as a guy. The takeaway from these exchanges is that gender is often linked to sexuality, but this is not always necessarily true. Identifying with a certain gender and sexual attraction are not always related. Although people that identify as one gender are often attracted to the opposite gender, it is not an absolute relationship.
Most people who are not transgender likely don’t view transgender people in the exaggerated form the episode suggest, but some parts of the episode more realistically relate to what occurs in the real world. Some people who are not transgender do view transgender people as different and the episode highlights this perception. When one of the transgender teachers is advising the principal on how to handle Cartman’s situation, she uses the term “cisgender” and explains how it is anyone who doesn’t identify with the sex they were born with. Another teacher responds by saying isn’t that just normal, implying transgender people aren’t normal.
Towards the end of the episode, it’s clear that the episode is intended to refute the approach that transgender people are not normal. Cartman and Wendy change their names to Erica and Wendell and claim to be transgender, but still act the same as they did before they claimed to be transgender. The episode intends to show that transgender is just a label and perhaps influences wardrobe and appearance, but is not a reflection of personality or interests.
There are likely people who would be uncomfortable sharing a restroom, or a public location of any sort specified for one gender, with transgender people and there is no real solution to this because, as the episode indicates, the transgender person might be uncomfortable themselves being forced to use a specific bathroom. As the episode suggests, at this point in history not to many people care what gender uses the bathroom as long as there is some degree of privacy, but at some point the issue of where transgender people fit in a gender divided society will likely have to be decided legally.
Clips of the episode can be seen here under the clips tab: http://southpark.cc.com/search/the+cissy
