There are questions that I know a majority of Americans don’t think about too deeply. One of these glossed over questions came to my attention in the form of a presentation a few weeks ago. The question that was posed was what is the meaning of America? I think the reason many people don’t cover this question in depth is that there are already statements that can efficiently answer this question. An example response to this question could be something along the lines of “well, America is the land of the free and home of the brave of course!” While there is some merit to statements like this one, they are generalized and don’t delve deep into what the true essence of America is. While no answer is the same for every person, acclaimed author and professor Danielle Allen gave her perspective on the issue and her response to the question what is the meaning of America?
When beginning her presentation, Danielle Allen talked about seeing if there was anything that the American people had in common regarding our national image. She cited a study in which the aim was to find a commonality between Americans on that subject. The commonalities I expected to see were ones referencing freedom, diversity, rights, democracy, and other similar words/phrases. This was when Ms. Allen surprised me and a few other people in the audience with the findings of the study. The one thing that Americans have in common about the view of our country is that we have nothing in common. This took me a few minutes to fully comprehend, but once she explained the premise more in-depth it began to make sense. After this she proposed a question to us, how do we go from sharing nothing to starting a collective understanding of America?
To answer the question she just posed, Ms. Allen turned our attention to the founding documents of our country, specifically the Deceleration of Independence. She said that to find common ground and collective understanding we have to comprehend what America was supposed to be like. She referenced various parts of the Declaration and Constitution but mainly highlighted the second sentence of the Declaration. When she summarized this sentence she said that it boiled down to three main parts, the first being rights, the second being good government, and the third a right to change. She went on to assert that it was our job as a nation to ensure these ideals for everyone. She also made mention that it is important that as a democracy we connect policy/institution to these values. In essence, the future of our democracy, or any democracy, relies on knowing what our shared values/contributions are.
After covering this aspect of a collective understanding of our country, Ms. Allen talked about what was being arranged to include these values into our government. She first discussed how John Adams and his wife Abigail were pushing for the inclusion of more of these rights in the Constitution when it was being drafted. Abigail focused heavily on pushing for women’s rights. Ms. Allen then talked more about the injustices and what has been done (or needs to be done) to correct them. She called these philosophical corrections to our founding government documents. She made mention of the line “all men are created equal” and reviewed the laws passed and policies implemented that worked to make principles of inclusion a reality and ensure that the government worked for and secured the rights of every American and not a select few.
The final aspect of her presentation was an interactive one. Ms. Allen had surveys that the group would take to inquire about our views of America and to respond using our own words to help prove the central concept of her presentation. I thought this activity was so interesting and it taught me a great deal about the views held by Americans.
This experience was such an eye-opening one and it was one that made me think surprisingly deep about what the meaning of America is to me. As a political science major and a politically active citizen, I had thought of the question and came up with answers, but this presentation made me take my thought process to the next level and gave me the tools and knowledge to assist me in explaining my views and better understand what it is that makes America great.