Initial Brainstorming Ideas

Here’s a link to a pdf of our initial brainstorming ideas:

Initial Brainstorming Ideas

As a team we came up with about 100 ideas based on the problem areas we defined: stability&balance, use of devices, vehicle height, handles, doors, body of vehicle, vehicle seat, process, medical conditions.

Reflection:

What went well? What went less well?

  • As we were brainstorming ideas we found some of our product categories were easier to come up with ideas for. We were able to think of many ideas to account for the height of the car but struggled to come up with ideas for helping the person maintain balance. We also struggled to come up with ideas once we had a bunch already. We found that many of our ideas started to overlap in many aspects and were very similar. 

What seems promising about your project direction at this point? What seems… less promising? (Keep in mind you’re not evaluating ideas yet!)

  • There seems to be a wide variety of areas that we could choose to focus on in terms of what part of the process or the vehicle to design a product for. Some of the ideas that we came up with were a bit out there so the range of possibilities for the solution to the problems that were determined in the “Problem Definition” assignment might be limited, even with the ~100 ideas the team came up with during brainstorming. 

What (if anything) might you need to research in order to improve your ideas for your next iteration of brainstorming?

  • In order to improve our ideas we might look into existing products on the market. Knowing more about existing products could help us to get inspiration and make sure that we are heading down a path that is novel. As we continue to brainstorm it might help to learn more about the structural components of a car and the materials it’s made out of. We have a fair amount of ideas that connect onto the vehicle, so it will be helpful to know what parts of a car are more feasible for connections.

 

Fully Collapsible Walker Prototype

 

This prototype idea looks at making a more easily collapsible walker. The solution aims to make it so that older adults can use their walker to enter a vehicle and easily store it near where they are sitting for easy use when they exit. It will mitigate the need to store a walker in a back seat or trunk which requires retrieval after exiting. In this prototype design the inspiration was a foldable baby stroller which has many joints that bend and allow them to fold up. To prototype this hinged joints on the legs were modeled so that the walker could fold up relatively small. The team is still exploring other ways to make a walker foldable such as with telescoping legs maybe.

Questions:

  1. How to make the design fold small (hinges, telescoping, folding, etc.)?
  2. Does the design fold up relatively small? How small?
  3. What ways can the prototype work with the limited dexterity of older adults?
  4. How can the walker be kept sturdy when in use but also collapsible when not in use?
  5. Can walker be collapsed while in a seated position of a car?

Extendable Seat Platform

 

This prototype was an example of an extendable seat platform to allow the user to have more room to sit down. This product would be stored by attaching it on the side of the seat in a vertical orientation. When in use, the user would fold the product down to a horizontal position, which would extend the two bars or supports to their full length. Then user would pull out the platform, which is made smaller plank pieces that can be used to sit on. When the user is done using the product, they can pull the platform back in, then flip the product back into the vertical orientation to collapse the supports.

Questions:

  1. How much space would be needed in order to have a similar product attached to a seat?
  2. How could the design be condensed into a smaller state?
  3. How much of a platform would be need in order to be beneficial?
  4. Is there an alternative way to create the same function of storing and putting out a platform?
  5. Would handles or a seatback be necessary for such a product to make the product safer/more ergonomic for use?

Rotating Seat

This prototype is a design for a rotating seat. There is a piece of cardboard that represents the stationary piece that will stay put on the seat. On top is a rotating piece of Styrofoam that represents a cushion that the person will sit on. This will help them sit in the car and rotate to face forward so they don’t have to twist by themselves. There is a handle on each side that allows the person to hold for balance and push on for leverage as they exit the car.

Questions

  1. How can we lock the cushion so the device stays in place while person is driving?
  2. Will the handles get in the way when the person is driving?
  3. How do we make the handle heights adjustable to account for people’s heights?
  4. What is the best way to connect the cushion to the stationary part?
  5. How high should the cushion be?

 

Seat Belt Prototype

Seat Belt Prototype:

 

The seat belt prototype is a product designed to help older adults put on their seatbelts. The problem experienced by older adults is that they cannot rotate their body to grab the seat belt. This product solves that problem by utilizing an arm that extends from the left side (if in the driver seat) and grabs the seat belt, pushing the seat belt strap forward so that it is more parallel with the older person’s body. This allows the older person to reach the seat belt strap without having to rotate.

Questions answered from the prototype:

  • Can the seat belt strap be reached without having to rotate your body?
    • Yes, the seat belt strap is able to be reached without rotating the body. The arm must be able to extend enough to put the strap about parallel to ones body while sitting down. The actual mechanism/mechanical design of the arm extending was not discussed during this rough sketch prototype.
  • Is this idea compatible with a vehicle (does the prototype fit/can it be attached somewhere in the car)?
    • Although this prototype was not brought into a car, and the mechanical design was not discussed, the prototype seemed compact enough to fit in a car. Pictures of vehicle interiors were examined and interior dimensions were studied. The prototype and prototype arm was able to fit in all interiors.
  • Is there an obvious way that this product can fail?
    • After the prototype way made, the group immediately realized that an obvious failure point of this product would be that the arm that pushes the seat belt forward, might “miss” the belt strap and fail to bring the strap forward. This was a failure that the group was able to realize only after making the prototype. This issue was solved by making a hook on the end of the pushing arm so that the belt strap has no way of slipping out.
  • Is there a better way/design to achieve the function of this product?
    • The idea of a rail system was discussed to the class, but it was brought up that this idea was implemented in vehicles before and failed. The rail system also adds more complexity and makes the process of getting in harder, which is not ideal for our users.
  • What methods of manufacturing might be used for this product?
    • From the prototype, it was found that only a relatively small force is needed to push the seat belt strap forward. This means that the hook, and maybe the arm could be made of plastic from additive manufacturing. If a smaller size is needed, aluminum could be used for the arm, which could be turned on a lathe.