“Paul Is Dead” Theory

by Lauren Hondroulis

The 1960’s were consumed with excitement and adoration for The Beatles as they became a worldwide phenomenon. Many fan-fueled theories sprung into sight over the course of their careers, but among the most outrageous is the “Paul Is Dead” theory.

Believers of this theory claim that singer and guitarist of The Beatles, Paul McCartney was killed in a car accident on November 6, 1966. This conspiracy theory became popular among the obsessive fanbase in 1969 as the result of a startling rumor and the release of Abbey Road. The news that the “real” Paul was dead and a fraud had taken his place spread quickly worldwide and even made it to The Beatles themselves. McCartney made light of the accusation saying, “If I were dead, I’d be the last to know”. The claims remained prominent amongst fans throughout 1969 until Lennon refuted the statements, causing them to die down. This conspiracy gained enormous traction due to McCartney’s terrific celebrity status and has remained one of the most curious in music history.

Clues that hint at Paul’s death have been extracted from many Beatles’ works. Fans have gone to great lengths in order to find obscure references in lyrics, album art, and even songs played in reverse. Fans famously picked apart the imagery found on the cover of Abbey Road. McCartney is pictured walking out of step from the rest of the band, barefooted, and holding a cigarette in his right hand. Theorists swore this was mirroring a funeral procession, while depicting Paul as the corpse. Allusions to death and funerals were further discovered within the artwork on Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band’s cover. McCartney and other member’s garb were scrutinized and inspected for further cues of the heartthrobs untimely demise. Fans also played The White Album’s Revolution 9 backwards in order to reveal hidden messages in the lyrics. Another key component of this theory is the fact that Paul was replaced with a lookalike stand-in. Many believers thought the replacement to be a man named Billy Shears. If this were true, the imposter would have talked, acted, and looked like Paul; as well as written the hit “Hey Jude”.

Several psychological factors come into play to make this conspiracy as widely noted as it is. Pareidolia might be an explanation for all of the evidence surrounding this claim. Defined as the tendency to see patterns in random data, this could have been what sparked the “Paul Is Dead” rumor in the first place. It is the brain’s natural inclination to make sense of the world, and oftentimes humans can derive meaning from noise. This is especially the case in circumstances involving the hidden messages found in The Beatles discography. It is difficult to pull out comprehensible phrases from the jumble of noise which comes from playing a record backwards. But, when primed to look for certain cues or words, the mind places significance on sounds it would not have otherwise, and hears the words it wants to hear. Believers ignore the impossibility of Paul’s death, looking only towards small and unconfirmed signs hidden in the music.

Celebrities are often targets of extraordinary conspiracy theories as they are always in the public eye. The Beatles were no exception, and this caused the belief to spread rapidly. Members of the fanbase maintained their position on McCartney’s death, attempting to bring mystery and scandal to the famed boyband. Pareidolia and overactive imaginations created a rumor that would not soon be forgotten. This conspiracy remains one of the largest in music history, and continues to bring amusement to McCartney and Beatles lovers around the world.

Works Consulted

“Conspiracy Theories.” Time, Time Inc., 20 Nov. 2008, content.time.com/time/specials/packages/article/0,28804,1860871_1860876_1860997,00.html.

RollingStone. “Paul McCartney Is Dead Conspiracy Theory, Explained.” YouTube, YouTube, 6 Nov. 2017, www.youtube.com/watch?v=_OPFr5ofkq8&t=43s.

“Paul McCartney: Music’s Most WTF Conspiracy Theories, Explained.” Rolling Stone, Rolling Stone, 6 Nov.2017,www.rollingstone.com/music/videos/paul-mccartney-musics-most-wtf-conspiracy-theories-explained-w511027.

5 thoughts on ““Paul Is Dead” Theory

  1. I thought this post was well written and very informative! This conspiracy theory is one I’ve always been interested in and intrigued by. I definitely agree with you that this belief has pareidolia at play, since the believers see random things, like song lyrics, as indication he is dead. They are therefore seeing random patterns in things that are not actually there. I also think another thing at play might be the fact that the fans are overly obsessed with the band and want to know everything about them.

  2. Conspiracies such as this one always make me laugh. It is crazy how unrealistic far die-hard fans can be. How they come up with these ideas amaze me as well. Who just decides one day that this is the story that they believe to be true.

  3. I have recently seen this theory circulating on social media and it’s so interesting how mistaken people can be about the so called “evidence” of his death. I wonder why people are so adamant about this being true and what they are getting out of it. As for the hidden messages in many of their songs and album covers, I have always wondered why they would hint that Paul is dead when they have supposedly tried so hard to make the public believe the look-a-like is him. In my opinion, he is well and alive and it is a funny theory to look at but I don’t believe there is any truth to it.

  4. This was really interesting, as a popular conspiracy theory is believing dead celebrities are alive instead of the opposite. I think its just wild that people will choose to believe that someone is dead no matter the contradicting evidence. If you are a hardcore fan, why would you want to believe that a musician you love is dead??

  5. Hello!
    This was an interesting topic for a blog post! I have read a few blog posts about famous people dying and being replaced. I think it all goes back to the idea that the world is suspicious and looking for ways were being secretly fooled. I think it would be crazy as a celebrity to have these theories be made about you! I think for sure, if a big celebrity actually died, there would be a huge memorial and wouldn’t just be replaced. Bands often break up or make due when losing members. I dont think its super logical that he secretly died and basic clone was able to take his place and everyone in his life acted like nothing was wrong. If so, that would be a crazy situation!!

Comments are closed.