Dr. Cate Williams, Institute of Biological, Environmental & Rural Sciences (IBERS), Aberystwyth University
(Previously published by Business Wales.gov: July 23, 2020)
How many of you still have wool on hand from last years wool clip? Have you decided when, where, and how you will sell it if at all? For those that are unsure, perhaps you could consider implementing a few of these alternative applications that would greatly benefit your operation this year and for many more to come.
- Sheep’s wool offers many benefits when used in a mixture as compost or mulch: as a source of slow-release nitrogen and other trace elements, in weed and pest control, moisture retention and temperature regulation.
- Wool may be used as a sustainable, renewable, and environmentally friendly alternative to peat.
- Other alternative uses include in thermal and noise insulation, particularly in the construction of new “eco-houses”.
- Further research is needed to establish optimum composting strategies and mixtures as well as how to upscale the process.
As the market for wool declines, producers may be looking for alternative ways to make use of their fleeces, particularly
daggings and dirty or low-quality wool. A couple of companies already commercially produce several ‘wool and bracken’ composts, a sustainable, environmentally friendly, peat-free alternative to some others. Sheep’s wool replacesthe peat element of other composts by increasing water retention and acting as a source of slow-release nitrogen. Peat extraction and use are problematic for several reasons, peat acts as a significant, natural carbon (C) store and so its removal decreases the land’s C storage capacity whilst increasing the risk of floods, impacting water quality and damaging wildlife habitats. Anecdotal evidence suggests that wool and bracken compost has a similar soft and crumbly texture to peat-based formulations with good nutrient profiles and water-holding capacity. Wool may also be included in mulch or mats where it has been shown to reduce predation by slugs and snails, eliminate weed growth, and reduce soil temperature variation. Wool has historically been used as an effective thermal and sound insulator and would be well suited to use in eco houses constructed using green materials. As a biodegradable, sustainable, and environmentally friendly material, wool has plenty of uses outside of the textile industry, especially in light of increasing concern regarding the world’s climate.
The problem with peat
Peat is a naturally occurring accumulation of decaying organic matter – consisting mostly of plants and vegetation. It is labelled as the most efficient carbon sink on the planet as surrounding plants capture the atmospheric carbon dioxide (CO2) originating from the decaying matter in the peat. A peatland or peat bog takes thousands of years to develop but can be destroyed by mining and harvesting in a fraction of that time, rendering it a non-renewable resource. Peat extraction releases large amounts of CO2, methane, and nitrous oxide, all potent greenhouse gases, as well as damaging wildlife habitats and increasing the risk of floods. Nevertheless, peat remains a key ingredient in the majority of commercially produced composts due to its water holding capacity and ability to effectively retain soil nutrients. Several other alternatives to peat have been explored, including biochar, wood, coconut fiber, and indeed, sheep’s wool.
Wool in compost
Whilst wool is fully biodegradable, this process takes a relatively long time – depending on the wool itself and the external environment this varies from 3 months to 2 years. This is a great advantage when composting, as this ensures a slow and steady release of nitrogen (N) into the surrounding soil – especially considering wool contains on average 10-11% nitrogen, more than some commercially available composts. Daggings are ideal as they contain dirt and fecal matter, which make for excellent compost material due to organic matter content. Wool offers a unique spectrum of trace elements too, studies have found comparatively high levels of potassium (K), sodium (Na), iron (Fe), and phosphorous (P). The very high concentration of K in sheep’s wool is due to a certain type of wool grease – suint. Whilst levels are not as high as N and K, P is also present in sheep’s wool, making up the full complement of essential, key nutrients found in fertilizers (N, P, and K). Some studies have found that wool may not need to be composted – results from trials using container-grown plants suggest that raw wool may be used as a nutrient source and growth medium, with roots growing directly and preferentially on wool fibers.
Wool in mulches and mats
Wool may be used below plants to prevent water and nutrient runoff, a method dating back to the 1900s. The presence of lanolin and other waxy substances on the outer surface of the wool makes it water repellent. However, the interior cortex is more delicate and contains a matrix of sulphur-rich proteins that attract water and make wool highly absorbent – a feature that is particularly important for dyeing.
As a mulch, used to surround plants above ground, sheep’s wool provides a porous shield that helps to reduce weed growth whilst regulating soil temperatures – keeping soil cool in the summer and warm in the winter. Numerous studies have shown the efficacy of wool mats used to quash weed growth with one noting that wool fabric nearly eliminated all weed growth, promoted daughter plant rooting and increased fruit yields in strawberries when compared to plants that were manually weeded and treated with a standard herbicide (chlorthal-dimethyl, DPCA). A similar study evaluating the use of wool mulch treatment in strawberries found that maximum temperatures were consistently lower and minimum temperatures consistently higher than those without wool. Overall, temperature variation was significantly lower for soil under the wool mulch. This study also agreed that wool mulch (single- and double-ply) is an effective barrier to weeds. Although not detailed in the scientific literature, there is anecdotal evidence to suggest that wool pellets might also deter slugs and snails, as some wool fibers have microscopic barbs which may act as a physical barrier.
Wool may be composted with a large variety of different materials, or for some uses may not need to be composted at all. Alternatively, wool may be processed into pellets – the pellet structure may allow for better soil aeration and porosity. Studies investigating composting strategies suggest that on a large scale, 25% wool, 25% horse muck, and 50% grass clippings may provide the best results. When compared to combinations with manure and woodchips and food waste and woodchips, the compost containing manure and grass clippings had the most appropriate moisture content, pH, temperature, and composting time. Most studies recommend the separation of wool before composting as it is prone to clumping and can become compacted when left in bundles which can lead to a high percentage of solids. Future research may look to mechanically separate compacted waste wool bundles before large scale composting. Overall, there is little research detailing optimum composting strategies for wool, with most anecdotal guidelines stemming from social media and small, private gardens. There will likely be variations depending on the breed of sheep from which the wool is sourced as wool fibers are highly variable in diameter and length. This may affect wool composition (e.g. trace element levels) which would have a knock-on effect on both its behavior in composting and value as a compost. Commercially available wool-based composts utilize wool from hill breeds of sheep [coarse wool], such as Herdwicks. The coarse wool from these breeds doesn’t degrade as quickly as finer wool which gives a better structure and texture to the end product as well as ensuring a slow release of nutrients and maintained moisture retention. Hill [coarse] wool is also often too coarse for use in textiles, so this also helps to support local farmers. Such commercially available wool composts also use bracken as a base which provides a good source of potash, helps to retain moisture and is freely available from the surrounding British countryside. Furthermore, bracken is well known for causing problems, overpowering and inhibiting the growth of surrounding plants using toxic chemicals. Such chemicals are broken down during the composting process making it safe and effective for use in compost. As bracken is invasive and problematic yet a renewable material (recovering in approximately 4 weeks) this makes it an attractive ingredient.
Wool in thermal and noise insulation
Wool has long been used as an effective insulator in terms of both sound and heat, but is now experiencing renewed interest due to it’s natural, sustainable, and renewable nature. In light of increasing attention concerning climate change and the environment, these qualities are becoming more and more important to consumers. There is also increasing interest in “eco-houses”, designing and building homes with minimal carbon footprints. To do so, houses must be well insulated to ensure good energy efficiency, so to this end, renewable and sustainable materials such as wool and indeed hemp and straw have been explored. Due to natural variation in wool, density can be inconsistent, meaning that a larger amount of wool is needed to produce comparable thermal effects to fiberglass, however, wool offers a myriad of advantages over fiberglass (e.g. sustainability and environmental impact, safety and toxicity, fire retardancy, and better noise insulation). Studies have found that wool effectively isolates vibrations and can reduce noise by up to 6 decibels, outperforming mineral wool. A recent study has found that coarse, low-quality wool performs just as well in insulation, offering the potential for diversion of this waste stream of less marketable and valuable wool into green building material which may offer some benefit to sheep producers. When comparing wool with polyester fibers, a study found that a 50:50 mix of the two performed best, absorbing over 70% of noise, displaying good moisture resistance under high humidity, and 65-70% biodegradation. The 50:50 mix outperformed both 100% polyester fiber and 100% wool, although it is worth bearing in mind that polyester is not biodegradable so 100% wool would likely be the more environmentally friendly option albeit not the most effective.
As the wool market continues to decline, particularly for hill breeds with coarse wool, alternative uses need to be explored. The use of wool in compost or mulch is a fairly novel concept, with only a couple of commercial producers of wool and bracken compost. Nevertheless, wool (soiled wool in particular) provides an excellent slow-release source of nitrogen in addition to a variety of other trace elements as it biodegrades. Wool offers further benefits in terms of soil temperature regulation, moisture retention, soil structure, and is an effective weed and pest control. Wool presents a sustainable, renewable and an all-round environmentally friendly alternative to peat, which is so often used in composts. Other applications for wool include in thermal and noise insulation, especially relevant in light of increased interest in sustainable and environmentally friendly eco-houses, constructed primarily from renewable and green materials.