Dr. Anelli described theories formulate by Plato and Aristotle in which species fit into distinct groups and there was a clear hierarchy of species. Dr. Anelli then went on to describe later books and theories formulated and written by naturalists (including John Ray and William Paley); however, Ray and Paley were associated with the Church and thus their theories reflected the idea that God created all creatures so they must be perfect and unchanging. Dr. Anelli then tied in ideas from the movie about Darwin’s personal life, family and influences with his theories, the social hierarchy during the Victorian Era and potential rejection of his ideas. Darwin’s theories directly conflicted with the idea that since God created creatures they could not go extinct nor could they undergo evolution.
I felt like the movie focused a lot more on Darwin’s personal struggles and his life, while Dr. Anelli gave us a broader picture of Darwin’s influencers, as well as the impacts his ideas have had on modern science and technology.
Yes, Kelly, I really like the movie in that it personalizes Darwin for many who see him just as a historic figure. His relationship with his family is not only touching, but also a big part of his life’s work, including his hesitation to make it public. I enjoy the way Dr. Anelli builds on what we learn from the movie to give a broader perspective of Darwin and his influence.