On Feb 11, 2020 I watched the Restoring Faith in American Democracy discussion! This was an academic event.
To begin, this discussion was absolutely phenomenal, and I really want to attend more in the future. I assumed that it would be focusing on the events of January 6th, and though this was a main point, the panelists broadened my view of the problem our country is facing in terms of faith in our Democracy. One of the panelists argued that this is not just a recent phenomenon, but that perhaps distrust is stemming from our government’s inability to address problems well in the past 50 years. That panelists also started discussing completely changing our democracy! This was all very surprising to me; I’ve only been alive for 18 years, and though I of course know of recent polarization, corruption, and violence in our politics, I haven’t considered that perhaps these problems have been going on long before 2016. Also, though I’ve always speculated different ways we maybe should change our democracy (like having proportional electoral college votes, rather than a winner-takes-all system), I’ve never imagined that America would ever change our two party system, or adopt something more parliamentary. This really broadened my hopes for the future, as I really agree that our democracy should change, but I’ve never dared believed that it would. I realize that I’ve been living with an assumption that this is how America has always been and always will be, but in reality, our country is only around 250 years old! Governments change! And, as the panelists said, change often comes in busts. While I was worried that January 6th would lead to a crumble of our democracy and perhaps the rise of anarchy, maybe our government and national structure could change for the better. I still have doubts, but I think this should be considered.
Something I really liked that one of the panelists said, is that we should build new “pillars” for our democracy; ones that are made with everyone represented. I think our country idolizes our Constitution too much. While it is of course important for us to have a unifying document of law (especially since recently in Sociology we’ve been discussing how the authority in our country is Legal-Rational, and thus based on law, so we need something to keep those laws consistent), I think our country’s refusal to consider changes is holding us back. The founding fathers knew that the constitution would likely change as our society and country develops, yet it is so hard for us to make any sort of modifications. Yes we have amendments, but I think it is a problem that our country is built on a document that was meant to encompass the rights of only rich, white men. We shouldn’t scrap all the ideas in the Constitution, but I completely agree that we need new foundations for our Democracy, and I think it should be easier to modify those foundations as our Democracy continues to develop.
Nevertheless, I’ve gotten a bit off topic. Another thing that the panelists discussed that opened up my perspective a little is that perhaps we should look into the past for solutions. She did say that history doesn’t repeat itself, but rather forms parallels, and though I would have to disagree with this (though perhaps I should listen considering she is a history professor), I thought this was a cool idea. Our country has set a lot of precedents, but we are not the first country to face huge divisions; this isn’t even the first time our country has faced huge divisions! However, there is always the question of whether past solutions would only doom us again in the future. Either way, I loved how this discussion talked so much about greater change that needs to happen, and that the problems our country is experiencing are not just recent.
I remember earlier last year my parents and I were discussing me acquiring Polish citizenship. They mentioned it would also be a good idea in case our country fell into corruption or dictatorship or something. I laughed this off, as my beliefs were always that although America has its problems, our Democracy could never fall – our people wouldn’t let that happen. I then remembered that my parents both watched that happen in their own countries, Syria and Poland, growing up. That conversation, and now this panel, made me realize that I have this unfillable belief in American Democracy that may be unrealistic, and that it may be holding me back from imagining and fighting for large-scale change that may be necessary.
In the end, I wished I had sent in my question about how we can restore other countries’ faith in our democracy. I remember watching the news on January 7th and noticing other countries’ responses to the Capital coup: calling out America’s hypocrisy, questioning our stability, etc. Furthermore, many countries were confused by our horrendous response (or lack thereof) to Covid-19. That said, other countries have been expressing concern in the state of our country even before the Trump administration. How can we restore their faith in us? Can we do that if our own people don’t have faith in our Democracy?
In the end, this was an absolutely fantastic discussion that opened up my perspective in many ways. It made me regret only taking stem classes, as I want to have more discussions like this myself!