Source: NYT (11/6/22)
Taiwan’s Bomb Shelters: ‘A Space for Life. And a Space for Death.’
Preparing for war over hundreds of years has left a mark on the island, with its hundreds of bomb shelters. Some are being turned into cultural oases.
By Damien Cave and Amy Chang Chien
KEELUNG, Taiwan — Visitors to Keelung, a mountainous port city on Taiwan’s northern coast, might reasonably think that the white wall at the back of Shi Hui-hua’s breakfast shop is, well, a wall. Only a few air vents suggest that there might be something on the other side.
“It’s a bomb shelter,” said Ms. Shi, 53, as she waited for the morning rush. “Because we’re Keelung people, we know these kinds of places.”
“It’s a space for life,” she added. “And a space for death.”
All over her street and many more in Keelung — which suffered its first foreign attack, by the Dutch, in 1642 — the landscape has been carved up for protection. Kitchens connect to underground passageways that tunnel into the sandstone. Rusty gates at the ends of alleys lead to dark maws that are filled with memories of war, and sometimes trash or bats — or an altar or restaurant annex.
There are nearly 700 bomb shelters in this city of 360,000 people, leading officials to declare that Keelung has a higher density of places to hide than anywhere else in heavily fortified Taiwan. And for a loosely organized band of urban planners, artists and history lovers, Keelung’s bomb shelters have become a canvas — for creative urban renewal and civil defense.
Some of these havens have been recast as cultural spaces. But these subterranean spaces are not just cool relics; on a self-governed island that China considers lost property it plans to reclaim, they are also vital infrastructure.
Most of the bunkers were mapped out and built by Japan, which governed Taiwan from 1895 until the end of World War II, when Keelung was a bombing target.
The shelters around Ms. Shi’s shop occupy one of the oldest parts of the city, sitting just below a hillside park that is being upgraded with an elevator. One of its entrances will soon require a short stroll through a cave with winding tunnels that, until recently, had been used as a fire department storage shed.
On a recent morning, it looked more like an art gallery or a nightclub. Rails of lights hugged the moist walls, shining on sprouts of green plants, the underground’s only bursts of color. Concrete floors had been laid with drainage areas on the sides.
Hung Chih-chien, 33, a public servant in Keelung’s urban planning division, said city officials had initially thought of opening up the space and making it a restaurant, then decided they didn’t want to ruin the original geology.
Keelung’s shelters are not easy to manage; deeds are rare, and access often defines possession. But the city found documents showing that this bunker had been built in the 19th century, near the end of the Qing Dynasty’s rule over Taiwan. It was one of several tunnels and bunkers built in that era, when China, weakened by famine and rebellion, struggled to hold on to territory.
In 1884, for example, the French invaded Keelung, seizing the city for about a year until the imperial commissioner for Taiwan, Liu Ming-ch’uan, pushed out French troops. Soon after that, to better secure Keelung, he commissioned construction of Taiwan’s first railway tunnel through Shihciouling Mountain, a natural barrier blocking Keelung from Taipei.
The tunnel opened in 1890 — and will reopen, renovated, in a few months.
On a recent tour, Kuo Li-ya, who heads up the cultural heritage department of Keelung’s local government, explained the complicated restoration effort, which included running small cameras above the tunnel to gauge the strength of the ceiling. She said she hoped it would eventually be connected to local hiking trails and roads.
“We want people to know the history, to know the way this helped protect Keelung,” she said.
For many in Keelung, past and present threats blur.
In recent months, China has increased the frequency and intensity of military drills off Taiwan’s coast. Xi Jinping, China’s leader, has also become more vocal about unification with Taiwan, reserving the right to use force.
At Pufferfish, a restaurant in Keelung that backs into a cavernous bomb shelter, tourists at the half-dozen wooden tables snap photographs of the interior. But locals favor dark humor.
“Many people told me if a war breaks out, they would come to my restaurant,” said Miao Hsu-ching, 34, Pufferfish’s owner. “They’re certain that we would still provide food.”
Growing up in Keelung, Ms. Miao felt it was a pity that many abandoned bomb shelters were filled with garbage and overlooked. For generations, children in Keelung have scared one another with stories of their ghosts, soldiers killed and killing.
“It’s important to renovate them and connect them with their surrounding areas,” Ms. Miao said.
Wang Chieh, 53, a painter in Keelung, has embraced that mission. A few years ago, he and 40 or 50 local residents fixed up four mossy blastproof walls that stand in front of bomb shelters on one of Keelung’s many hills. Inspired by the city’s rainy weather and folk beliefs, Mr. Wang sketched out a mural design with widely sprawled ferns and a mythical beast that is carved on the gate to a well-known temple in the city.
It took six months to complete the paintings on white tiles. Now the blast walls and bunkers are a tourist attraction, and a landmark of pride.
“The civil society was the main driver of the renovation,” Mr. Wang said. “The younger generation was able to reflect on the past when the older generation played — or even hid — inside.”
To some, a fondness for the shelters seems strange. Ms. Shi said she saw a snake in the one behind her shop — beyond the storage room — and has no intention of going in there, even if missiles start flying.
She said Keelung’s shelters should be renovated mainly to make young people — whom she called soft, a “strawberry generation” — pay more attention to the tensions with China that may force them to fight or hide.
For some of her neighbors, the bunkers are a reminder of their past.
A few doors down from her shop, Wang Huo-hsiang, 91, sat at the store where he made rubber stamps, before he retired.
He remembers when the Americans bombed Keelung in 1944 and 1945, recalling the bump, bump, bump of the bombs he heard while hiding in a shelter nearby.
He slept in one tunnel at night, he said, lived by day in another. He was just a boy, in fifth grade, but the memory made him smile. The shelters had rescued him.
“That was the only safe place to be,” he said. “They were filled with people.”
He and his wife later spent summer nights in the man-made caves, hiding from the heat. They’d share a drink and food, talk to friends.
“It was like an air-conditioner in there,” he said. His wife, Wang Chen Shu-mei, stood behind him. She laughed and agreed.
But when asked if they could imagine returning to the shelters in case of another attack, they both frowned. Ms. Wang Chen began to yell.
“We’re Taiwanese, we have nothing to do with China,” she said. Then, she spoke quietly: “We don’t know when the bombs will come. We hope they never come.”