Ambiguous Loss

Have you ever had the feeling of grief or loss without closure? If so, perhaps you were struggling with something called ambiguous loss. If you’ve ever dealt with breaking up with someone, a child moving to college, aging parents, or your own degenerative health condition, you have most likely experienced ambiguous loss. In the 1970s, Dr. Pauline Boss termed this type of grief as ambiguous loss to describe a feeling of loss without closure, originally studying families of Vietnam War soldiers who went missing in action. This research was expanded to examine other situations where the loss remains unclear: family members disappearing in natural disasters, families separated at international borders, caregiving for dementia, divorce, stillbirth, and many more.

Research tells us that ambiguous loss is a relational disorder brought on by the lack of facts surrounding the loss of a loved one. Ambiguous loss differs from other types of loss in that there is either no confirmation of death or no certainty that the person will return to the way they used to be. This type of loss can not only be confusing, but it can also prevent resolution of the loss, which can freeze the grief process, leaving individuals and families stuck in their grief and impair normal functioning. People don’t deal well with ambiguity under normal circumstances, and in the dealing with loss, ambiguity poses even more of a challenge. Our minds use closure to help understand the situation and process grief.

Woman, sunset, trees

The pandemic posed a unique dilemma in that everyone experienced loss of one sort or another. No one got any closure on the former way of life before the pandemic required us to adapt to a chaotic new way of life. Many of us have experienced grief for all we have lost.

Thankfully with this research as well as the accounts of those who struggle with it, there are some ways we can deal with ambiguous loss.

  • Name what you’re feeling. Labeling what you’re going through might be the first step toward healing.
  • Work toward acceptance. Find a way to make peace with the situation and live with ambiguity.
  • Pet a guinea pig. Well, it doesn’t have to be a guinea pig, but any pet can offer comfort and lighten your grief.
  • Get support from others. Open up to a close friend or family member so they know what you’re going through.
  • Look for the positives. Ponder how this new way of life has brought you new relationships.
  • Find meaning through action. You will not only feel better in having helped others, you may connect with others that have gone through something similar.
  • Seek help when needed. If you continue to have trouble coping, seek out a therapist who specializes in grief counseling.

Writer: Shannon Carter, Extension Educator, Family & Consumer Sciences, Ohio State University Extension, Fairfield County, carter.413@osu.edu

Reviewer: Christine Kendle, Extension Educator, Family & Consumer Sciences, Ohio State University Extension, Tuscarawas County, kendle.4@osu.edu

Soucres:

Boss, P.  Ambiguousloss.com. 2023. College of Education and Human Development, Department of Family and Social Science, University of Minnesota. https://www.ambiguousloss.com//

Stephens, E. The Countdown We’ve All Been Waiting For… Jun 29, 2023. Live Healthy Live Well, The Ohio State University. https://livehealthyosu.com/2023/06/29/the-countdown-weve-been-waiting-for/

What Ambiguous Loss Is and How To Deal With It. A psychologist shares ways to cope with a lack of closure. Feb. 17, 2022. Health Essentials. Cleveland Clinic. https://health.clevelandclinic.org/ambiguous-loss-and-grief/

From Languishing to Flourishing

 

sun shining on a bed of wildflowers

As health restrictions are lifting from the pandemic, I have been able to interact with more people in person. When others ask how I’m doing, I say “fine” … but what I really want to say is “meh.” I’m doing okay… not depressed… but not great either. I find that I really have to psyche myself up for another week of work, and for certain tasks at work and home. I usually rise to the occasion, but it takes a lot of energy to overcome the urge to seek the solitude or even the isolation that I thought I couldn’t wait to escape.

A colleague pointed me to an enlightening article on languishing and it captured so much of what I have felt in the past few months. Psychologists describe languishing as slightly withered, wilted or faded. The pandemic has left a lot of people feeling this way. Initially, the pandemic may have incited feelings of fear, anxiety, dread and paralysis… and as these feelings have faded, they have left languish in their wake.

Emory University Professor Corey Keyes has been publishing about languishing since 2002, but it took the pandemic to bring greater attention to this work. Keyes describes languish as the absence of feeling good about life and lacking purpose or meaning in one’s life. Languish is the middle ground between depression and optimal well-being or flourishing. While depression is clinically diagnosable with the presence of certain behaviors, languish is feeling indifference, emptiness, and stagnation. Keyes’ research found languish to be a predictor of developing depression and anxiety as well as increased risk of suicide attempts. We need to acknowledge and treat languish so it doesn’t turn into depression later, and so we can live our best lives.

How do we move from languishing to flourishing? Thankfully, there are research-backed steps we can take. In fact, there are entire programs at universities dedicated to helping others flourish: The Human Flourishing Program at Harvard University, Institute for the Study of Human Flourishing at the University of Oklahoma, and The Wellbeing at Work project at the University of Notre Dame. Here are some of their highlights:

Name your feelings – It helps to identify emotions and give them a name. Once you identify languish and name it, you can start to deal with it. You might start to notice examples of it all around you in family members, friends, co-workers.

Find your flow – Flow can be described as feeling fully engaged or even engrossed in an activity that motivates and excites you. For me recently, that has been home improvement projects, from the smallest detail like a broken switch plate cover, to larger re-wiring or painting projects. As long as I have something to keep me focused, I can find my flow. As one project concludes, I line up another. Perhaps the activity that will get you into flow is learning something new. The act of learning a new task or skill can engage your brain and sharpen your focus.

Free yourself from disruptions – Give yourself what your brain might be craving: time to become engrossed in an activity and let it captivate you. We find joy and purpose when we can gain a sense of progress on an activity or task.

Focus on a small goal – Is there a goal you can set to increase your skills or strengthen your resolve? Find a challenge that is meaningful to you and commit time to it each day.

Cultivate gratitude – Recognize and savor the good in your present situation. Imagine your best possible self, and volunteer or provide acts of kindness for others to make your best self a reality.

Start wherever you are… and if that is languish, decide to take a small step toward blooming and flourishing. If languish is like a fading photograph, then imagine steps toward flourishing as a color touch-up, bringing vibrancy back into your life. Share your journey with someone, as you just might help them out. It could be refreshingly authentic to answer ‘meh’ next time someone asks how you are doing.

Written by: Shannon Carter, Extension Educator, Family and Consumer Sciences, Ohio State University Extension, Fairfield County

Reviewed by: Jenny Lobb, Extension Educator, Family and Consumer Sciences, Ohio State University Extension, Franklin County

Sources:

Grant, A. (2020). There’s a Name for the Blah You’re Feeling: It’s Called Languishing. New York Times. Published April 19, 2021, Updated May 5, 2021

Keyes, C.L. (2002). The Mental Health Continuum: From Languishing to Flourishing in Life. Journal of Health and Social Behavior, 43(2), 207-222. doi:10.2307/3090197

Keyes, C. L., Dhingra, S. S., & Simoes, E. J. (2010). Change in level of positive mental health as a predictor of future risk of mental illness. American journal of public health100(12), 2366–2371. https://doi.org/10.2105/AJPH.2010.192245

VanderWeele, T.J. (2017). On the promotion of human flourishing. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.A., 31:8148-8156.