
Fall is upon us, and if you’re like me, you’ve already started making a list of comfort foods to make this season.
Comfort food means many things to different people and looks different across the world, but one commonality is that it makes us feel good. For some people, comfort food stirs up an emotional connection about a family tradition or particular family member. The snacks or dishes we reach for may even be a way of handling stress or coping. When I think of comfort food, I think of dishes that make me feel warm, full, and fuzzy. Comfort food also has a biological connection. The food we choose triggers a complex response in our brain that triggers an emotional association to our food. Hence why we might feel more inclined to eat these memorable dishes throughout the holiday season or when thinking of a particular person, place, or time. Additionally, as the weather cools, our bodies crave more calories to help keep warm – even though we may not need them.
When we enjoy comfort food, it is usually a meal with higher fat, carbohydrate or sugar content. We tend to think of these meals as indulgences, or something unhealthy to savor. However, there are many ways to experience our favorite comfort flavors. Here are some easy, healthy substitutes to make even the best comfort foods a little lighter and healthier.
- Plain Greek Yogurt – yogurt is a good swap in many recipes as it reduces fat and adds protein and calcium. Plain Greek Yogurt can be used in place of butter, milk, sour cream, mayo, cream cheese, buttermilk, and heavy cream. You can find an easy conversion chart by clicking here.
- Applesauce- In most baked goods you can use applesauce in place of butter and oil. My family’s favorite banana bread uses applesauce.
- Cauliflower- This vegetable has made a come back in the recent years! You can use cauliflower in pizza crust, breadsticks, riced, or mashed. In my house we enjoy cauliflower as a substitute in Shepard’s pie instead of mashed potatoes.
- Lean Protein- Replacing high-fat meats such as sausage with lean proteins like turkey help to reduce the fat content of a meal. This is especially useful in recipes that use heavy creams, cheeses, and butter. In some recipes it is easier to replace the protein then the cheese.
- Extra veggies- If a comfort go to this season is pizza, chili, or mac and cheese, focus on adding more veggies. You can add veggies in place of some or all of the meat. Vegetables are full of nutrients like fiber and low in saturated fat and calories. Adding more vegetables to your dishes will reduce their fat, salt and calorie content.
- Beans and legumes- Bring on the beans! Beans are making a comeback as a great source of protein and fiber! Consider trying a chickpea pizza crust, noodle, or dessert. Swapping out a traditional noodle will not only add protein to your spaghetti, but can help offset the carb crash afterwards. Beans are also a great substitute in baking! My family loves to enjoy black bean brownies.
There are so many ways to enjoy comfort food this season. If you are hesitant to experiment with new ingredients, a simple way to keep things healthier is by watching portion sizes. Trying to measure portions for casseroles can be challenging, but using a smaller plate such as salad plate can be helpful.
Allow yourself to explore some of these swaps, try new recipes, or experiment with family favorites. By adding healthier ingredients, we are giving our bodies more of the nutrients it needs to stay healthy all year long! Who knows, maybe you’ll create a new recipe for friends and family to enjoy when they think of you or reach for a seasonal favorite.
Written by: Holly Bandy, MEd, CHES, Family and Consumer Sciences Educator, OSU Extension Stark County
Reviewed by: Jenny Lobb, MPH, RDN, Family and Consumer Sciences Educator, OSU Extension Franklin County
Sources:
Harvard Health. Comfort food without the guilt. (2019). https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/comfort-food-without-the-guilt
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. (2023). Healthy eating for a healthy weight. https://www.cdc.gov/healthyweight/healthy_eating/index.html