Riddle Final Drafts

Final Daft 2

Black lettering with translucent

  • Pros- Invisible from distance, overall shape is concealed from front view
  • Cons- only legible from very close

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Notice how becomes very visible the back reads “N” at only certain angles. Also, the front is a backwards “N” shape, yet does not read as so. This detail makes the riddle’s solution less obtainable from outside the door.

 

 

 

 

 

Final Draft 1

Black lettering with white negative space

  • Pros- Defined edges, mirrors handicap sign, easily read
  • Cons- Very obvious, more noticeable than the other two signs

Hidden in Plain Sight Original Plan

E&P

  • Line- 2 stacked squared windows (VERY FLAT)
  • Light -Natural and artificial
    • Bright when sunny
    • Door frame very dark
  • Color– Dark frame, but slight white/tan highlight around window
  • Texture- smooth; muted, matte reflection
  • Movement– open and closes- conceals solution
  • Gestalt p-similarity in using same typeface throughout
  • Parts to the whole– the parts of the riddle create the whole solution

Function/Meaning

  • Riddle about window and door
  • Use the riddle to create the answer
  • The riddle is about how changing one bit can result in a different outcome overall

 Materials/Tools

  • Use laser cutter
    • Chip board/ paper/possibly vellum (depends how see through)
  • Use just Text
    • Thin, geometric text
  • Experiment with paint if mirroring the door frame
    • Spray paint for furniture
    • Matte overcoat
  • If use vellum, keep slightly transparent
    • As long as shadow appears

Changed Plan

Due to the lack of sun during the past week, my original idea of revealing the solution in the shadow of the door’s window was not viable. I still wanted to convey the message of the parts combining to create the whole (the answer). To remedy this, I decided to change my material to clear vinyl and make it a window decal. The door already possess other decals, so the riddle will blend in with those. Furthermore, in reference to the riddle’s line “but bring me back through the door”, the observer can see the answer on the backside of the decal after they have gone through the door. Color and lack of color is now a contrasting component to my new design. The text will be filled, and the negative space will flow with the translucency of the window.

Hidden in Plain Sight Concept Statement

Draft 1

The intention of this design is to present a riddle hidden in plain sight through the use of shape, contrast, and emphasis. The location it is concealed in is a back-entrance way to one of Hayes Hall’s stairwells. Using the geometric framing of the door, the riddle and answer will play in the heavy contrasting light. During the day, light floods the two stacked, rectangular windows; thus, a box on the inside ground is formed. This dark frame is how the answer will be exposed as the Gestalt principle of figure-ground will express the letter “N” (the answer). In conjunction to this bright highlight, the internal door frame is darkened, a component to cloaking the riddle. The riddle with rest in this darkened area visible to only those meticulously searching. The riddle will mirror the straight, geometry of the door through a typeface of similar qualities. The riddle will read the following, “If you throw me from the window, I will leave a grieving wife/Bring me back in the door, and you’ll see someone giving life.” The idea behind it is the think of how one missing piece changes everything, but as a whole can be something else. This idea will be seen in how the riddle itself will pull into an outline of an “N”, which inside will reflect its shadow on the ground. By using natural light to present the secret the riddle requires intentional visitation and timed observation. This causes the audience to interact with the creation at various points. By hiding something in plain sight the space provides a level of focus not always given from the various visitors. This provides an enigma and interest quality to the area. The observer must undergo this transition and be aware of the image as whole, not as individual parts. Overall, this will cultivate a linear process of paying attention to the door’s parts, then the sign’s text, as well as the complete image once inside.

 

Draft 2

The riddle of “if you throw me from the window, I will leave a grieving wife/Bring me back in the door, and you’ll see someone giving life” is being hidden in the back-entrance way to one of Hayes Hall’s stairwells. The elements and principles incorporated in the concealment are shape, contrast, and emphasis. The heavy light quality and closed line qualities of this space will harmonize with the riddles text to expose the answer, “N”. Using the geometric framing of the door, the riddle and answer will play in the contrasting light. During the day, light floods the two stacked, rectangular windows; thus, a box on the inside ground is formed. This dark frame is how the answer will be exposed as the Gestalt principle of figure-ground will express the an “N” shape. In conjunction to this bright highlight, the internal door frame is darkened, a component to cloaking the riddle. The riddle with extend this darkened area in the window, blocking part of the light from entering. The text will create the negative space of the “N”. The riddle will mirror the straight, geometry of the door through a typeface of similar qualities. The idea behind the riddle in the doorway is to make the observer think of how one missing piece changes everything, but as a whole can be something else. This idea will be seen in how the riddle itself will pull into an outline of an “N”, which inside the room will reflect its shadow on the ground. By using natural light to present the secret the riddle requires intentional visitation and timed observation. This causes the audience to interact with the creation at various points. By hiding something in plain sight the space provides a level of focus not always given from the various visitors. This provides an enigma and interest quality to the area.

Draft 3

The riddle of “if you throw me from the window, I will leave a grieving wife/Bring me back in the door, and you’ll see someone giving life” is being hidden in the back-entrance way to one of Hayes Hall’s stairwells. The elements and principles incorporated in the concealment are shape, space, and movement. The transparency of the window and pre-existing signs of this space will harmonize with the riddles text to expose the answer, “N”. Using the movement of the door, the riddle and answer will play in the entering and exiting of the building. The riddle is only read on the outside, but mirrored in the back of the text is the answer. This will incorporate the Gestalt principle of figure-ground relationship, for the reverse positioning of the text is read as the letter “N” in the negative space. The text will emulate the straight, geometry of the door through a typeface of similar qualities. The idea behind the riddle in the entryway is to express the meaning of parts to a whole. The concept is about how adding and removing just a singular component creates new meaning, similar to how being part of the building or out of the building changes an entire perspective. Doorways signify the moment of change, just as the letter “N” does in those words.The observer must undergo this transition and be aware of the image as whole, not as individual parts. Overall, this will cultivate a linear process of paying attention to the door’s parts, then the sign’s text, as well as the complete image once inside.

Draft 4

The riddle of “if you throw me from the window, I will leave a grieving wife/Bring me back in the door, and you’ll see someone giving life” is being hidden in the back-entrance way to one of Hayes Hall’s stairwells. The elements and principles incorporated in the concealment are shape, space, and movement. The transparency of the window and pre-existing signs of this space will harmonize with the riddles text to expose the answer, “N”. By having a similar quality of line and shape the window decal will match the preexisting stickers. Although the text color and size will differ, overall color scheme and positioning will match. Using the movement of the door, the riddle and answer will play in the entering and exiting of the building. The riddle is only read on the outside but mirrored in the back of the text is the answer. This will incorporate the Gestalt principle of figure-ground relationship, for the reverse positioning of the text is read as the letter “N” in the negative space. The text will emulate the straight, geometry of the door through a typeface of similar qualities. The idea behind the riddle in the entryway is to express the meaning of parts to a whole. The concept is about how adding and removing just a singular component creates new meaning, similar to how being part of the building or out of the building changes an entire perspective. Doorways signify the moment of change, just as the letter “N” does in those words. The observer must undergo this transition and be aware of the image as whole, not as individual parts. Overall, this will cultivate a linear process of paying attention to the door’s parts, then the sign’s text, as well as the complete image once inside.

Edit: I added the specifics of the elements that harmonize with the door’s surroundings and traits.

 

Spacial Analysis

 

Chosen Location

This was my final selection for my space. The sharp contrast in light plays well with my concept of parts to a whole. The lines create a definitive frame and foundation for my construct. Additionally, the solution to my riddle is exposed only during a certain time and lighting, playing in the idea of hide and reveal.

 

 

 

 

Other Considered Locations