Hanna, S. D. (2000). Award winning authors. Financial
Counseling and Planning, 11(1), iii-iv.
Award Winning Authors
Sherman D. Hanna1
There is a subjective element in choosing which manuscripts will be
included in a refereed journal. The standard process in research journals
is a double blind process to increase the chance of fairness, and the editors
I know do their best to choose competent reviewers. I realize, however,
that many frustrated authors may wonder about the process. Financial
Counseling and Planning is an interdisciplinary journal, so I cannot
be certain that all decisions are reasonable.
There are some sources of external validation, though, for instance,
when authors have won or later win awards. I thought of this recently when
a representative of the Certified Financial Planner (CFP )Board contacted
me about two articles that had each won a $1,000 prize awarded for outstanding
articles related to financial planning. Both of the award-winning articles
appeared in Volume 10 (1) of Financial Counseling and Planning,
Cooley, Hubbard and Walz (1999) and Lee and Hogarth (1999). I went through
old “About the Authors” in previous issues, and also searched the CFP Board
web site, and found a large number of awards from different sources going
to authors of articles in this journal. Some of the awards were for articles
in other journals, some were for dissertations, and some were for conference
papers. Some of the awards were received before the authors published an
article in this journal, and some were received after the author had published
in this journal. I listed some of the awards in Table 1. There are many
other awards not listed, as I limited the entries to ones with multiple
winners among authors who have published in this journal.
Clearly, even this limited sample of awards shows the impressive array
of authors who have published in
Financial Counseling and Planning.
There are many other excellent authors who have not received awards, partly
because there are more awards related to financial planning than there
are awards related to financial counseling. The number of awards should
instil some confidence in the reviewing process.
This issue has a variety of topics, including some not previously covered.
The article by Lown and Su should remind us that AFCPE is an international
organization – the “A” does not stand for American. The increasing need
for financial counseling and planning around the world will increase the
importance of comparative studies. Just as other countries can benefit
from lessons learned in the United States, educators and researchers in
the United States should benefit from research and position papers related
to other countries. Other articles in this issue have a variety of topics
and approaches, some quantitative and some qualitative, some empirical
and some theoretical. As usual, the authors have an impressive list of
accomplishments, as can be seen in the “About the Authors” section in this
issue.
Table 1
Selected Awards Won by Authors of Articles in
Financial Counseling
and Planning.
Award | Recipients Who Have Published in Financial
Counseling and Planning |
Dissertation Award of the American Council
on Consumer Interests |
Jessie X. Fan
Jonathan J. Fox Charles B. Hatcher Eun-Ju Lee Catherine P. Montalto Jing J. Xiao |
Certified Financial Planner Board Award for
Best Article (including awards tied to ACCI, ACFPE, and general selections by the Board.) |
M. J. Alhabeeb
Peng Chen Philip L. Cooley Sharon A. DeVaney (5 times) John E. Grable Sherman D. Hanna Gong-Soog Hong Carl M. Hubbard Craig Israelsen So-hyun Joo Constance Kratzer Deanna Sharpe Ya-Ping Su Jing J. Xiao Daniel T. Walz |
Applied Consumer Economics Award of the American
Council on Consumer Interests |
Sherman D. Hanna
Jeanne Hogarth Jinkook Lee Kathryn D. Rettig Michael L. Walden (3 times) |
McGraw-Hill Award for paper presented at
the Academy of Financial Services meeting |
Regina Chang (2 times)
Jessie X. Fan (2 times) Sherman D. Hanna (2 times) Premal P. Vora |
Texas Instruments Award for a paper presented
at Academy of Financial Services meeting |
Jonathan J. Fox
Sherman D. Hanna Catherine P. Montalto (2 times) Yoonkyung Yuh |
References
Cooley,
P. L., Hubbard, C. M. & Walz, D. T. (1999). Sustainable withdrawal
rates from your retirement portfolio. Financial Counseling and Planning,
10(1),
39-47.
Lee,
J. & Hogarth, J. M. (1999). Returns to information search: Consumer
mortgage shopping decisions. Financial Counseling and Planning,
10(1),
49-66.
1. Sherman D. Hanna, Professor, Consumer Sciences Department,
The Ohio State University, 1787 Neil Ave., Columbus, OH 43210-1295. Phone:
614-292-4584. Fax: 603-457-6577. E-mail: hanna.1@osu.edu
Return to
journal home page