Benjamin Libet’s Experiments on Free Will

by

In class the last couple of weeks, we have been discussing the free will debate. In this post, I would like to bring to light an old research study pertaining to free will. Benjamin Libet was a famous 20th century neuroscientist who conducted groundbreaking research on the neurobiology of consciousness. In one of his classic experiments, Libet taped electrodes to the intact scalp of his study volunteers in an attempt to measure the correspondence of electrical signals from their brains. His goal was to measure this correspondence of electrical signals when the volunteers moved their wrists. The volunteers were required to look at a moving clock and take note of the precise time (to the millisecond) that they consciously decided to move their wrist. Following data collection, Libet compared the timing of brain activity with the timing of the volunteers’ decisions to move their wrist. His results showed that the volunteers’ brain activities preceded their conscious awareness of the decision to move their wrists by ~200 milliseconds.

Libet’s results sparked a debate about whether the volunteers’ decisions to move their wrists was predetermined or an act of free will. Those supporting the former claimed that because the volunteers’ brain activities preceded their decisions, it was in essence “predetermined” that the volunteers would subsequently move their wrist. On the other hand, those arguing for the free will side such as Libet himself claimed that there was a possibility for the volunteers to override the brain’s “proposal” to move the wrist at a given time. For instance, Libet argued that there was a brief period between the initiation of brain activity and the volunteers’ awareness of the intention to act during which they could “veto” the brain’s decision to initiate movement a moment after. If they did so, then they would prolong the initiation of movement. In this way, Libet argued that the volunteers exercised free will in deciding to veto the brain activity.

Libet’s justification reminds me of Kane’s businesswoman example in his article about free will, in which she has two conflicting decisions but ends up choosing one voluntarily (out of free will). In the same way, I feel that Libet’s volunteers must have had this internal conflict (whether to initiate movement a moment after as the brain specified or veto the brain’s decision), but consciously chose one (to veto the brain’s decision) over the other as an act of free will. As such, I feel that the free will defense of Libet’s experiments is more plausible than the determinism defense.

Source: http://www.evolutionnews.org/2014/01/do_benjamin_lib081171.html

117 thoughts on “Benjamin Libet’s Experiments on Free Will”

  5. از دهه 1950، شلوارهای جین با تناسب، پایه و اساس مجموعه‌های غیررسمی بوده‌اند و به راحتی بالا یا پایین می‌پوشند. اگر می‌خواهید یکدست‌تر به نظر برسید، یک شلوار جین صاف و باکیفیت انتخاب کنید. برش هایی را با رنگ های روشن تر انتخاب کنید تا ظاهری آرام تر و خارج از کار داشته باشید. جین یک استایل همیشگی و همه کاره است که بدون توجه به ظاهری که انتخاب می کنید، می توان آن را به طرق مختلف پوشید.

    استایل کژوال چیست

    Reply

  7. سال‌های اولیه لویی ویتون در عصری آغاز شد که بخار، قایق و کالسکه اسب‌کشی روش‌های اصلی سفر بودند. مهارت ماهرانه Vuitton در ساخت صندوق عقب باعث شد که او قاب های روی هم پشته ای پیشگامانه ایجاد کند که هم ضد آب و هم مانند یک پر سبک بودند. تا به امروز، تنه های لویی ویتون، با آرم های مونوگرام و سیستم های تک قفل فنری غیرقابل انتخاب انقلابی، بسیار مورد توجه و قابل جمع آوری هستند.

    تاریخچه لویی ویتون

    Reply

  11. چرم مصنوعی که به عنوان چرم مصنوعی نیز شناخته می شود، جایگزینی برای چرم طبیعی بر پایه نفت است. در حالی که چرم مصنوعی بسیاری از ویژگی های مطلوب چرم طبیعی را دارد، برای ایجاد این ماده لازم نیست به حیوانات آسیب برساند.

    بیشتر بخوانید: چرم مصنوعی چیست

    Reply

  15. 1. چرم واقعی باید بوی چرم واقعی را بدهد: اگر بوی چرم واقعی نداشته باشد، احتمالا واقعی نیست. بسیاری از چرم های مصنوعی با رایحه ای تقلبی اسپری شده اند تا مشتریان را فریب دهند. برخی دیگر ممکن است بوی پلاستیک یا مواد شیمیایی داشته باشند (مخصوصا اگر به یک کیف پول تمام چرمی نگاه می کنید). اگر می خواهید یک مبلمان اصیل بخرید، همیشه باید قبل از تعهد آن را امتحان کنید.

    چرم مصنوعی

    Reply

  24. MAHADBT stands for Maharashtra Direct Benefit Transfer. It is a government portal in the Indian state of Maharashtra that allows citizens to access various welfare schemes and services online.

    Reply

  28. Like all medicines, Kamagra can cause side effects although not everyone gets them. However, reported side effects associated with the use of Kamagra or sildenafil are usually mild and of short duration.

    https://kamashop.kr

    Reply

  33. Dewataspin is the first online slot agent to use the best undeductible credit deposit slot system that provides trusted online slot games with
    Rtp Slot Gacor in Indonesia. Only by using 1 ID, you can hardly play various games.

    Reply

  36. 비아그라(sildenafil)는 남성의 발기부전(ED) 치료에 사용되는 약물입니다. 그것은 발기를 생성하고 유지하는 데 도움이되는 음경으로의 혈류를 증가시켜 작동합니다.

    비아그라의 효과는 일반적으로 약 복용 후 30분에서 1시간 이내에 나타나며 최대 4시간까지 효과가 지속됩니다. 그러나 비아그라가 작용하는 데 걸리는 시간은 연령, 전반적인 건강 및 복용량과 같은 요인에 따라 달라질 수 있습니다.
    https://www.viagrakorean.com/

    Reply

  41. TARUNABOLA adalah salah satu pilihan yang tepat untuk dilakukan. Pasalnya anda akan bisa mendapatkan jaminan permainan yang 100% aman dan fair play, akses permainan nya bisa dilakukan dengan menggunakan Handphone dan PC, Disini kami juga menyediakan BOCORAN SLOT dengan RTP TerUpdate Setiap harinya, Selain itu kami juga menyediakan transaksi deposit tidak hanya menggunakan rekening bank saja, tapi juga bisa menggunakan pulsa, dan juga e_wallet. Disamping itu kami tawarkan juga berbagi sumber penghasilan seperti jackpot dan SLOT GACOR HARI INI serta promosi promosi lainnya setiap hari dan setiap minggunya.

    Reply

  42. Bigo88 Gaming is one of the many online slot game provider
    sites with bets applying authentic Indonesian money. On this page you will not only be able to enjoy slot games online.

    Reply

  46. Pragmatic play is one of the most well-known Slot Gacor Hari ini and is the best slot game both in Indonesia and internationally.
    Pragmatic Play is the best recommendation for you and won the most complete best of online slots award of all time.

    Reply

  48. I am very impressed with your writing totosite I couldn’t think of this, but it’s amazing! I wrote several posts similar to this one, but please come and see!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *