A Summary and Reflection of Prof. Tyler Doggett’s Video on “Killing Animals for Food”

Having watched the optional video (Professor Tyler Doggett’s video on “Killing Animals for Food”), I feel there is strong evidence that it is not morally acceptable to kill animals for food. Prof. Doggett starts off by asking the following question: if it is morally acceptable to kill animals (he specifically chose to use pigs as an example) for food, is it morally acceptable to kill people (human beings) for food? Obviously, we can all agree that the answer to the latter question would be no. Why then would it be ok to kill pigs for food? What is the difference between humans and pigs? Doggett discusses a number of possible responses one may offer, but I list just a couple here that I thought he argued particularly well against: humans and pigs have different genetic makeups and humans are stronger (higher up in the food chain). Let’s consider the first difference one may offer, that humans and pigs have different genetic makeups. In his hypothetical example, Doggett says to consider the case that aliens come to Earth and decide to farm humans. Their justification in doing so is that aliens and humans have genetic differences, so it is morally acceptable for them to farm humans. However, if humans shouldn’t kill other humans for food, why should aliens kill us for food? Exactly, they shouldn’t. If we translate this idea to the humans/pig scenario, it is clear that even though pigs are a different species than humans, it is not morally permissible for us to kill them for food. Now to the second response, that humans are stronger. That is, the response that humans are higher up in the food chain. Doggett argues that even if humans are higher up in the food chain, it is not morally acceptable to kill those lower down in the food chain for food. This is because if we take the example of 2 humans, one stronger than the other, it would obviously be wrong for the stronger to kill the weaker. Similarly, he argues, even if humans are stronger than pigs, it is not morally acceptable for humans to kill pigs for food.

Personally, I feel that Prof. Doggett makes a strong case for why we should’t kill animals for food, although he does not specifically address the issue of whether it is wrong to consume them. Perhaps one may argue that humans kill animals for food simply because they can? This seems to suggest that humans are in some way superior to other animals and therefore deserve extra rights. As Regan would argue, this would be blatant speciesism. One could argue against this and say that animals kill animals for food all the time in nature, but as a more intellectually evolved species, I feel that we humans should exercise better judgment and consider the perspective of the animals we are slaughtering. Therefore, like Doggett, I personally don’t believe it is morally acceptable to kill animals for food.

Source: http://www.wi-phi.com/video/killing-animals-food

23 thoughts on “A Summary and Reflection of Prof. Tyler Doggett’s Video on “Killing Animals for Food”

  1. I agree that Doggett does provide a strong argument against killing animals for food and proving that it is morally wrong. It’s bad but I never really thought about how morally wrong it is to kill animals for food because it is what I’m used to. I guess it all depends on the type of culture and tradition a person grows up in. It also depends on the way they kill animals. Animals are getting mass produced and mass killed in factories.

  2. Doggett contends that even if humans are at the top of the food chain, it is immoral to slaughter animals at the bottom of the food chain for food. Restaurant Setop This is so that it is clear that it would be wrong if two humans, one of whom is stronger than the other, were to murder the other.

  3. One could argue against this and say that animals kill animals for food all the time in nature, but as a more intellectually evolved species, I feel that we humans should exercise better judgment and consider the perspective of the animals we are slaughtering.
    Kiddions Mod Update

  4. Đây là một blog thông minh. Tôi nói thật đấy. Bạn có quá nhiều kiến thức về vấn đề này, và quá nhiều đam mê. Bạn cũng biết làm thế nào để khiến mọi người tụ tập đằng sau nó, rõ ràng từ các phản hồi.

    https://www.bacarasite.com/

  5. My nespresso coffee machine has been a great addition to my kitchen since I’ve had it for a time. Making a good cup of coffee or espresso is really simple. Additionally, the machine’s modern design gives my countertop a bit of class. I agree that the reusable coffee pods are a huge benefit since I care about the environment. Nespresso has really won me over with its quality and ease.

  6. eggy car is fun driving game recently released with beautiful and eye-catching graphics. Difficulties always need your attention. Overcome challenges safely.

  7. Professor Tyler Doggett’s video on “Killing Animals for Food” provides a thought-provoking exploration of ethical considerations in our dietary choices. This discourse holds particular relevance in Health and Social Care, where professionals often encounter diverse perspectives on nutrition and well-being. In an assignment example on health and social care, incorporating insights from Doggett’s video could prompt students to analyze the ethical dimensions of dietary practices

  8. dog fence Pittsburgh, also known as invisible or underground fences, offer an alternative to traditional fencing by using a buried wire and a collar equipped with a receiver to create a virtual boundary. When the dog approaches the perimeter, the collar emits a warning tone followed by a mild static correction if the dog continues to advance.

  9. Elevate your salon with TipTop-Einrichtung’s top-notch Friseursalon Einrichtung. Our range includes modern and functional elements, from chic chairs to efficient workstations, creating a welcoming environment. At TipTop-Einrichtung, we specialise in providing tailored solutions to enhance your hairdressing space. Discover simplicity and sophistication with our comprehensive hair salon facilities.

  10. Looking to level up your vacation wardrobe? Dive into our pool-side perfect collection of the latest must-have women’s swimwear. From bikini separates that are sure to bikini dubai earn you some serious style points to effortlessly chic swimsuits, we’ve got your swimwear game covered this season. Get ready to turn heads at the beach club party with swimsuits and women’s bikinis in this season’s must-have prints and hues.

Leave a Reply to Kezia Sta-Ana Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *