The cinematic classic Breakfast at Tiffany’s, released in 1961, is not a movie I’d typically be interested in. I’ll freely admit that I’m not a fan of old movies, finding the antiquated social rules and styling to be frustrating and dull. However, Netflix didn’t get the memo, most likely because it’s a shared account, and suggested it to me about a year ago. Although certain elements date the movie (Mickey Rooney’s stereotyped Mr. Yunioshi for one), the overall character-driven plot is innovative and relevant. The central themes of money, prostitution, and love transcend an era.
Audrey Hepburn stars as Holly Golightly, a beautiful socialite with a complicated past. Her stark apartment is one of several in a beautiful New York City townhouse, containing the photographer Mr. Yunioshi and the newly arrived writer Paul Varjak. An unlikely friendship blossoms between Holly and Paul, rooted in the complex relationships they have with the opposite sex. Paul has published a series of short stories, and in the ensuing years, been taken under the patronage of an older, wealthy woman who pays for his room, rent, and suits, in exchange for his love. His writing has stagnated over the years, as he “saves himself” for the Great American Novel. His relationship with this married woman is not one we typically see in mainstream cinema, there are a greater number of examples of men in the position of dominance over a younger ingénue. This emasculation of Paul allows for him to be a nonthreatening presence in Holly’s world, stripping him of the need to inhabit the stereotypical gender role of a man.
In contrast, Holly’s life is defined by the men who inhabit it. Through a series of anecdotes and side characters, we get a clearer picture of the factual details of her past, although we rarely get insight from Holly herself. The first man to provide the viewer insight to Holly is a man who sidles up to Paul at a party to ask him, “Is she or isn’t she a phony?” The man is O.J. Berman, her former agent, who reveals that Holly was a country girl discovered by Berman. He provided her speaking lessons before sending her out for screen tests for movies in Hollywood. Holly decides to move to New York on her own instead of sitting for the tests. She is also a frequent visitor to Sing Sing prison, where she sees former mob boss Sally Tomato. His lawyer pays her to visit once a week, in exchange for a “weather report” from the inmate. Sally has taken over as Holly’s accountant as well, and reads Paul her expenses, noting it was a sad story in the making. The lingering mentions of $50 from men to “go to the powder room” alludes to sexual encounters with these men for money. Paul later meets Holly’s ex-husband, whom she married at 14, in order to provide a place for her mentally-disabled brother, Fred. Her subsequent annulment from Doc Golightly still hasn’t registered with the man, but he eventually leaves with the ominous message that she must take care of Fred now. In desperation, Holly makes the decision to pursue a marriage with a rich Brazilian, José, who eventually leaves her via a letter delivered by Paul after her arrest in conjunction with a scheme from the aforementioned Sally Tomato. These men continue to impose their own image of Holly over her personage, trying to make her only one thing: a wife, a mother, a call girl. In their vain attempts to “tame a wild thing,” we see a person who needs someone to understand and love her true self, not a visage of perfect beauty or womanhood.
The concluding minutes fall into the classic romantic kiss in the rain trope, as Holly realizes that she’s in love with Paul after she releases her pet cat into a dirty New York alleyway. The cat comes back, and the theme song overwhelms us, as they walk off into the sodden sunset. The difference in overall feeling, however, between this ending and a Taming of the Shrew-type ending are prevalent in the equality of the situations faced by both Holly and Paul and their common ground in needing to see the other’s true self. However, the marriage proposal does some damage to the claim that they have transcended their time, because with marriage comes the aura of respectability, finally, for Holly. Do we see a fully realized Paul and Holly? Or do we see them falling into the relationship ideal for a man and a woman? If the prior hour and fifty minutes have taught us anything, it’s that this is a relationship built on mutual respect for the other person, under the layers of stereotypes and expectations.