Transcript
Hi guys, my name is Lily Collignon, and today we’re going to be talking about colorism, but specifically, colorism seen in the beauty industry. So what is colorism? The national conference for community and justice, also known as the NCCJ defines colorism as a practice of discrimination by which those with lighter skin are treated more favorably than those with darker skin. I’d also like to run through some statistics that can also explain colorism further. A 2016 University of Georgia study showed that employers prefer light-skinned men to dark-skinned men, regardless of their qualifications, from MS magazine, dark-skinned defendants are more likely to be convicted and receive the death penalty than lighter-skinned ones. So these are just a couple of examples of how colorism can actually affect people’s lives negatively, and the different abilities that they can have.
So, where does this all come from? And where did this obsession over a lighter complexion begin? There are many events in history that created this ideal of light skin, and I’m going to walk you through a few of them. To start out, hundreds and hundreds of years ago. The only women who had pale complexions were those who didn’t have to work outside, so pale skin was associated with wealth and high class. But then in the 19th-century women began consuming arsenic wafers that would make their skin paler because of the association with the class in lighter skin. Also in India, around the same time, they had white rulers, which are said to be the reasons why many Indian people fascinate lighter skin. So again, they’re associating the white rulers with power and their wealth, and it’s associated with lighter skin. In the 1950s colorism continues, advertisers are now marketing products to African American women that are said to lighten their skin, which is supposedly going to lead them to be more beautiful, more socially liked can even marry better
In one of our in-class readings, the story of my body by Judith Ortiz Colfer. She delves into her upbringing and the many physical components of her life that have shaped who she has become. In her early teenage years, she remembers hearing a Puerto Rican woman say, “I hope my baby doesn’t turn out prieto, which is slang for dark and black.” This is an example of how colorism has affected an individual who feels as if her daughter or son- if they had darker skin wouldn’t be as liked, or have the same abilities as somebody with lighter skin.
In the past decade, there have been tons and tons of products marketed to everyone solely for whitening and brightening the skin. Today I’m going to talk about Tarte makeup that launched a brand new foundation. And it only had 15 shades. And I’m going to put the link to the article as well as a picture so you guys can see this for yourself. So the shade range ranges from 15 shades. And if you look at this picture it’s quite stirring. Only three of these shades are for darker-skinned people, and there are many many more shades of other individuals out there with darker skin complexions than just these three shades. The other shades are all pertaining to white skin. After much controversy tarte insisted that they had more shades coming that are already in the work. I’m not sure whether I believe this or not, especially because I looked into it, and tarte actually launched their quote-unquote full shade range of the foundation. In February of 2020. So that would have been 13 months after this swatch photo, and when the first 15 shades came out. I think it’s great that they ended up having more shades for people but at the end of the day, they came out with 15 shades that were completely prioritizing and pertaining to individuals with lighter skin.
Tarte isn’t the only makeup brand that has been guilty of colorism. Even right now if you were to look at Ulta which is a makeup store and you scroll through the concealer page, you will notice that almost every concealer shade on the cover page pertains to a lighter skin complexion. How does this affect the black community? Well, I have no idea. But I did do some research and I found in an article black voices colorism is a plague in the black community. Jacey Bledsoe interviews fellow students on the topic of colorism and asks them a series of questions. I read through all these questions I found it particularly insightful, but my most favorite question and the response comes from DeDjreanna Thames. And she says “it affects the black community because the world is already hurting in discriminating against us as it is. It doesn’t help that we are putting each other against one another as well because we are too light and dark, instead of fighting the fight against America together. We are fighting each other.” I think that Thames makes a really great point here. And she’s basically just trying to say that- And I mean it’s just putting it into perspective that there are many problems in the world and one of them is equality and discrimination and, and just making everybody equal regardless of skin tone and for individuals to be saying you’re too dark, or you’re too light.. is just taking us in the wrong direction for a diverse yet unified nation. I would like to make the argument that much of the beauty industry chooses to other members of the black community with their marketing efforts and product availability in relation to skin tone, the beauty industry looks at individuals with white and light skin as the one and prioritizes them because this skin tone is associated with idealistic beauty in what’s favored by society.
Beauty brands are continuing this horrific act of colorism and discrimination by continuing to sell these products and market mainly to individuals with lighter skin. I certainly think the beauty industry has the power to reshape ideologies and show that all skin color is beautiful ideal and valid. A lot of the time, makeup is associated with feeling pretty or dressing up, or feeling beautiful and looking beautiful. Right. And when big brands, choose to only market their products to individuals with lighter skin, they’re saying that only these individuals get to feel beautiful, but all colors are beautiful and invalid in able to feel pretty right. If you’re interested in a brand that supports black individuals and has a diverse shade range. And prioritizes all skin tones equally. Check out Juvias place, I actually have a product for them. And I really like it. They have so many shades and they market all their products using shades starting from dark to light, which was the first makeup brand to do that. So a lot of the time when you go to makeup counters, you’ll see products. And you’ll notice the next time you’re in there, but it’ll be like light to dark. Why, why, why is it not like medium to dark to light or dark to light it’s just interesting that’s just one of those things, but Juvias place if you go to their cameras you’ll see dark to light and even if you look up their page, you’ll, you’ll see uh, it’s just really cool, and you’ll see the difference to compared to Tarte per se. But yeah, a lot of the start to change colorism and is going to begin with the decisions that you decide to make in society. And thankfully tarte fixed their problem to a degree and didn’t just leave it. I don’t even know if they came out with an apology, but they were certainly othering black people when they came out with this line and making white complexion the one and it’s just interesting to think about it in that perspective.
But yeah, thank you so much for listening, and even you can make an impact by putting a stop to colorism just by the choices you make in society and the products in brands, you choose to buy and support. Thank you so much for listening. I’m going to link all of the articles of everything and some photos for you guys to look at just to get even more understanding, obviously, I’m not a pro on this topic I’m still learning as much as you guys are too and it’s just very eye-opening to read these kinds of things. So, thank you so much again, and I look forward to reading your guys’ “Yo is this podcast”s! Thank you.
Work Cited
Adamu, N. (2019, March 21). Colonialism and the origins of skin bleaching. Welcome Collection. https://images.prismic.io/wellcomecollection/ee63db55ad29f4e9078a5244e9f23f8c0be4f9dd_arsenic-complexion-wafers-smithsonian.jpg?auto=compress%2Cformat&rect=&w=1338&h=
Baragona, L. (2018). Fans are furious after Tarte unveiled its new foundation that cater almost entirely to white people. The Insider. https://www.insider.com/tarte-cosmetics-shape-tape-foundation-range-2018-1
Bledsoe, J. (2020) Black Voices: Colorism is a plague in the black community. Indiana Daily Student. https://www.idsnews.com/article/2020/11/black-vocies-colorism-is-a-plague-in-the-black-community
NCCP. (2021) Colorism. https://www.nccj.org/colorism-0
Newby. B (2019) Tarte Relaunched Shape Tape Foundation Due To Shade Range Outrage. The Reviliest. https://www.revelist.com/beauty-news-/tarte-relaunched-shape-tape-foundation/14634
Ortiz, Judith Cofer “The story of my body” Osman, N. (2019, April 4). Under the skin: How lightening creams exploit the beauty myth. Middle East Eye. https://www.middleeasteye.net/discover/skin-lightening-creams-are-they-exploiting-beauty-myths-south-sudan
Sankaran, S., Sekerdej, M., & Von Hecker, U. (2017). The role of Indian caste identity and caste inconsistent norms on status representation. Frontiers in Psychology, 8. doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00487