Rory Lewandowski, OSU Extension Educator ANR, Wayne County
Pulling from the archives, we found it timely and appropriate to share this piece from our very own Rory Lewandowski as he reviews the benefits of implementing the FAMACHA© eye scoring system in your operation. Here at the university, we began our summer grazing project with 96 lambs, all of which will be FAMACHA© eye scored every 14 days over the course of the study as one of five measurements to track parasitism. Proper use of the of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system will be sure to prove beneficial to you and your flock/herd over the course of this grazing year.
A number of sheep and goat owners have been trained across Ohio in the use of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system, yet problems with internal parasites, in particular, with Haemonchus contortus continue. This is to be expected. The FAMACHA© eye scoring system utilizes an eyelid scorecard that can help a farmer make a decision to treat or not to treat the animal with a chemical de-wormer. The FAMACHA© eye scoring system is not a cure-all, or a silver bullet for dealing with internal parasites. It is one tool that can be a part of an overall parasite control strategy. In order for this tool to be effective it must be used correctly. Let’s start with what FAMACHA© is designed to do and then look at the limitations of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system.
To begin with, the FAMACHA© eye scoring system is only useful when dealing with the Haemonchus contortus parasite. The Haemonchus contortus is the parasite of greatest concern to pasture based sheep and goat production, so FAMACHA© matches up with this concern. Haemonchus contortus is a blood sucking parasite and heavy infestations with this parasite may result in anemia. The symptoms of anemia show up in the color of the membrane of the eyelid. In the FAMACHA© eye scoring system that eyelid color is matched up with a scorecard that ranks color on a 1 to 5 scale. A dark red eyelid membrane color is a 1 and indicates no significant anemia. A white color is a 5 and indicates severe anemia. The light red, pink and pinkish white colors in between indicated by scores 2 through 4 indicate increasing levels of anemia that generally correspond to the parasite burden the animal is carrying.
Second, the FAMACHA© eye scoring system is to be used to help make decisions about selectively de-worming animals. In general, if an animal scores a 3, 4 or 5, it is treated with a chemical de-wormer. Selective de-worming is important to minimize parasite resistance to chemical de-wormers. FAMACHA© should not be used to make a decision to either treat or not treat the entire flock/herd. Finally, it is effective only when used on a regular basis.
The FAMACHA© eye scoring system has limitations. It is labor intensive. Each sheep/goat and lamb/kid must be handled and scored. As previously mentioned, its effectiveness really depends upon regular use. As we enter June, July, August and September, be aware that these are traditionally months of heavy Haemonchus contortus infections. Due to their smaller blood volumes, lambs and kids with heavy infections can go from apparently healthy to death’s doorstep in 10-14 days. This means that animals should be FAMACHA© eye scored every 7-10 days during this period.
I know that because of lack of handling facilities, or because of where animals are located in a pasture rotation system, it becomes problematic to score every animal every 7-10 days. I hear livestock owners say that they grabbed a couple of animals out on pasture and looked at their eyes. This quick spot check of a couple of animals is used to determine the parasite burden of the flock or herd. This is not a correct use of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system and is not likely to provide accurate information. Research has demonstrated that 20% of the animals in a flock or herd can carry 60-80% of the worm load. If a majority of the animals are not checked, how do you know if the animal grabbed was one of those 20% that has a heavy parasite burden, or is an animal with a relatively low burden? In addition, correct use of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system dictates that a scorecard, as shown in the image above, is used each time eyes are checked. Do not rely upon memory of scorecard colors.
At some point, the time and labor required to FAMACHA© eye score every animal becomes impractical as flock/herd size becomes large. Exactly what that size is, I can’t say, but certainly flocks/herds of several hundred and up are not all that excited about using FAMACHA© eye scoring system. With flocks/herds of several hundred and up it probably is not necessary to check every animal. Statistically, if a significant number of animals are checked, this will provide reliable information about the entire flock or herd. It will not provide specific information about individuals that are not scored. Still, there is a necessity of bringing animals to a handling unit and checking a considerable number. In any case, FAMACHA© scoring is a good tool for small and medium sized flocks/herds. Of course the FAMACHA© eye scoring system is of limited usefulness if the farmer does not know the level of chemical resistance present in the herd/flock and which, if any, of the chemical classes will act as an effective chemical rescue treatment.
To really get a handle on what is happening with regard to infection levels in the flock/herd, FAMACHA© eye scores should be recorded and the livestock owner should look for trends. Are the number of animals that scored a “1” or a “2” staying the same over scoring periods or is there an increasing percentage of 2’s, and some 3’s while the number of animals scoring a 1 is decreasing? If the trend is toward higher scores that is an early warning that pastures have a high level of parasite eggs and infective L3 larvae and that animal infection levels are increasing. This is where the usefulness of the FAMACHA© eye scoring system shows up, as well as its limitation. If there is not an overall parasite control strategy to effectively use the information FAMACHA© has provided, then the health status of the animals will continue to degrade.
An overall parasite control strategy takes into account the biology and lifecycle of the parasite. Effort should be made to reduce egg shedding on pastures and to reduce the incidence of young animals grazing on heavily contaminated pastures. When FAMACHA© score trends indicate a growing infection, plans should be made to move animals to a safe pasture, increase the nutritional plane of the animals and to FAMACHA© score animals every 7-10 days. Animals that score a 3 or higher should be treated with an effective chemical de-wormer. Treatment and movement to new pasture paddocks should be made with the intention of keeping a “refugia population,” a population of parasites that are susceptible to chemical de-wormers, on the pastures.
As a tool, FAMACHA© eye scoring can tell you when a parasite infection problem is developing, and which animals should be treated and which animals do not need to be treated. It can be a tool to slow down parasite resistance to chemical de-wormers. It is a tool that is most effective when used within an overall parasite control strategy.